Skip to main content

Exit options

Selling a Life Insurance Policy vs Surrendering It: The Tax Math and Your Rights

Buying and cost mechanics · Updated October 30, 2026

You can sell a life insurance policy you own to a third party in a transaction called a life settlement. The buyer pays you a lump sum that, under the rules in states such as Washington, must be more than the policy's cash surrender value or accelerated benefit, and less than the death benefit. The buyer then pays the premiums and collects the death benefit. Your beneficiaries get nothing from that policy.

Selling is one of five ways out of a policy you no longer want, and it is the only one that hands the death benefit to a stranger. This guide puts the five exits side by side, works the seller's tax arithmetic using the IRS's own published examples, and lists the disclosures and cancellation rights that state settlement laws give owners. It does not predict whether any buyer will bid on your policy, or how much. Nobody can say that without your policy, your health records and the buyer's underwriting. Education only. This site does not sell insurance and does not provide quotes.

Sources and dates: how we check each figure.

What a life settlement is, in the regulators' words

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners consumer brochure Selling Your Life Insurance Policy: Understanding Life Settlements (NAIC, 2022 file, checked October 30, 2026) defines a life settlement as "the sale of a life insurance policy to a third party" for a cash payment "that is less than the full amount of the death benefit." The buyer becomes the new owner or beneficiary, "pays all future premiums" and collects the full death benefit when the insured dies.

The same brochure draws a line between two names for the same mechanics. When the seller has a terminal or chronic illness, the sale is called a viatical settlement. When the seller is not ill and is selling because dependents' needs changed, the premiums became a burden, or cash is needed, it is called a life settlement. The distinction matters for tax, as the worksheet below shows, because federal law excludes viatical proceeds for terminally and chronically ill insureds and treats an ordinary life settlement as a taxable sale.

Three parties usually appear. The provider is the company that buys the policy and becomes its owner. The broker, if you use one, represents you and shops the policy to several providers. The NAIC brochure notes that the buyer pays the broker a commission if the sale completes, which is money that comes out of the same pool your offer comes from. Behind the provider there are often investors who fund the purchase and may later resell the policy. The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance viatical and life settlements page (checked October 30, 2026) describes buyers as individuals, investors and investment groups, and explains that the investor's return depends on the insured's lifespan: the buyer earns more the sooner the insured dies.

That last sentence is the uncomfortable center of the product, and it is worth saying plainly. A settlement is priced on an estimate of how long the insured will live. The shorter the estimate, the higher the offer tends to be, because the buyer expects to pay fewer premiums and collect sooner. That is why buyers ask for medical records, why they keep in contact with the insured after the sale, and why the state laws discussed below put limits on both.

The five exits, side by side

An owner who wants out of a policy, or needs cash from it, usually has more than one door. The New York Department of Financial Services consumer booklet Life Settlements: What You Should Know Before Selling Your Life Insurance Policy (checked October 30, 2026) lists the alternatives a seller should ask about first: a policy loan, a cash value withdrawal, a reduced death benefit, and an accelerated death benefit if the insured is terminally or chronically ill. The NAIC brochure adds that cash value may be usable as security for a loan from a financial institution. The table below adds the two remaining exits, lapse and surrender, and compares all of them on the questions that decide the choice.

ExitWho pays youWhat your beneficiaries keepFederal income tax, in outlineCan you undo it?
Let it lapseNobody. Premiums stop and coverage ends, after any grace periodNothing from this policyNo sale proceeds. If a cash value policy lapses with a loan outstanding, ask the insurer whether it will issue a Form 1099-RSometimes, through the contract's reinstatement provision, usually with evidence of insurability
Surrender to the insurerThe insurer, at the cash surrender valueNothing from this policyIRS Publication 525: proceeds above your cost are income, reported on Form 1099-R. Rev. Rul. 2009-13 treats that gain as ordinary incomeNo, once processed
Accelerated death benefitThe insurer, from part of the death benefit, while the insured is aliveThe death benefit minus what was accelerated, and any charges the rider statesExcludable for a terminally ill insured, and for a chronically ill insured within the limits in Publication 525No, but the policy stays in force for what remains
Loan, withdrawal or reduced death benefitThe insurer (loan or withdrawal), or no cash at all (reduction lowers premiums)The death benefit minus any unpaid loan and interest, or the reduced amountLoans and withdrawals follow their own rules, with special rules for a modified endowment contract; see the taxability guide linked belowA loan can be repaid. A reduction usually cannot be reversed without new underwriting
Life settlementA licensed provider, at an offer that state law in Washington requires to exceed the surrender value or accelerated benefit availableNothing from this policy. The NAIC says the buyer becomes the new owner or beneficiaryTaxable sale unless the viatical exclusion applies. Gain splits into ordinary income and capital gain under Rev. Rul. 2009-13 as modified by Rev. Rul. 2020-5Yes, inside the state rescission window, by repaying the proceeds and the premiums the buyer paid

Two rows deserve a second reading. First, the settlement row is the only exit where a beneficiary's expected payment goes to an investor instead. If the original reason for the policy was a spouse, a child or an estate cost, that reason has to be gone, or covered some other way, before a sale makes sense. Second, the accelerated benefit row is not available to everyone: it depends on whether the policy has the rider and on the insured meeting the contract's definition of terminal or chronic illness. Our rider cost math guide explains how those riders are defined and charged.

The ordering most regulators imply is the same: look inside the policy first, then at other sources of cash, and sell only after those are ruled out. The NAIC brochure tells owners to "contact your life insurer to learn about all of your possible options under your policy" and to review "other sources of cash that may meet your financial needs at a lower cost than a life settlement." That is a regulator saying, in its own consumer brochure, that a settlement can be the expensive way to raise money.

Why the offer sits between surrender and death benefit

Washington's settlement law, chapter 48.102 RCW (checked October 30, 2026), builds the price range into its definition. A life settlement contract is one where the compensation paid is "less than the expected death benefit of the policy," and the statute adds that "the minimum value for a life settlement contract shall be greater than a cash surrender value or accelerated death benefit available at the time of an application." In other words, in that state a transaction at or below what the insurer would pay you directly is not a life settlement at all.

Between those two walls, the price is a buyer's calculation, and its ingredients are public even though the result is not. The buyer estimates how long the insured will live, how much it will pay in premiums over that time, what return it wants on its money, and what the transaction costs, including broker compensation. A policy with high ongoing premiums relative to its death benefit leaves less room for an offer, because the buyer must fund those premiums. A universal life policy whose cost of insurance has risen sharply is the classic example; our guide to universal life cost of insurance increases shows why those premiums climb with age. Some owners receive no bid at all, and the NAIC brochure is clear that "you don't have to accept any life settlement offer" even when one arrives.

Because the offer depends on a life expectancy estimate, a seller should know which estimate the buyer used, and whose. Washington's disclosure rules require the owner to be told about contact with the insured "for the purpose of determining the insured's health status," and New Jersey's page warns investors that a life expectancy that proves too short can turn an illustrated return to zero or less. The same uncertainty runs the other way for the seller: there is no rule that the offer reflects your own view of your health.

The seller's tax worksheet, after the 2017 basis change

Before 2018 the IRS required sellers to reduce their basis by the cost of insurance they had received over the years, which made more of the sale price taxable. The 2017 tax law changed that. Section 1016(a)(1)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code, as shown in the Office of the Law Revision Counsel text of 26 U.S.C. 1016 (checked October 30, 2026), now says no basis adjustment is made "for mortality, expense, or other reasonable charges incurred under an annuity or life insurance contract," and the effective-date note applies the change to transactions entered into after August 25, 2009.

The IRS then rewrote its own examples. Rev. Rul. 2020-5 (Internal Revenue Bulletin 2020-9, checked October 30, 2026) modifies Rev. Rul. 2009-13 (Internal Revenue Bulletin 2009-21, checked October 30, 2026) so that basis is the premiums paid, without the cost-of-insurance reduction. The character rules from 2009 stay in place: the part of the gain that reflects inside build-up is ordinary income, and anything above that is capital gain if the policy was held more than a year.

Worked example from the IRS rulings

These figures are the IRS's own illustration in Rev. Rul. 2009-13, Situations 1 and 2, with the result as modified by Rev. Rul. 2020-5. They are not a market price or an offer anyone will receive. The owner bought a cash value policy, paid $64,000 of premiums with no loans or distributions, and in year eight could surrender it for $78,000. Instead the owner sells it to an unrelated buyer for $80,000.

LineSurrender to the insurerSell to an unrelated buyer
A. Amount received$78,000$80,000
B. Basis (premiums paid, no cost-of-insurance reduction)$64,000$64,000
C. Total income or gain (A minus B)$14,000$16,000
D. Ordinary income (cash surrender value minus basis, capped at C)$14,000$14,000
E. Long-term capital gain (C minus D)None. Rev. Rul. 2009-13 says surrender produces no capital gain$2,000

Read the table for what it really says. On these IRS figures, selling put $2,000 more in the owner's hands before tax than surrendering, and that extra $2,000 was taxed as a capital gain rather than as ordinary income. Any broker compensation or transaction cost not already netted out of the $80,000 would shrink that margin. Either gain also counts in adjusted gross income, which sets Medicare's income-related premium surcharge and how much Social Security is taxed (see surrender gains, Medicare surcharges and Social Security tax). A sale that looks dramatically better than surrender usually involves a policy whose surrender value is small compared with its death benefit, which is a different policy from the one in the ruling.

The same rulings include a term policy. In Rev. Rul. 2009-13 Situation 3, as modified, the owner had paid $45,000 of premiums on a term policy with no cash value and sold it for $20,000. Under the post-2017 rule the basis is the full $45,000, so the owner has a $25,000 long-term capital loss. Rev. Rul. 2020-5 notes the loss is deductible only if it arises under section 165(c)(1) or (2), which cover losses in a trade or business or a transaction entered into for profit. For a policy bought to protect a family, a tax professional should confirm whether any deduction is available before you count on one.

Your own version, line by line

  1. Offer. Write the gross offer and the net amount you would actually receive. Washington requires the broker to give you "a complete reconciliation of the gross offer or bid by the provider to the net amount of proceeds," so this figure should be on paper.
  2. Basis. Add up the premiums you paid. Publication 525 describes cost for surrender as premiums paid "less any refunded premiums, rebates, dividends, or unrepaid loans that weren't included in your income." Ask the insurer for its cost basis figure, and note any outstanding loan.
  3. Cash surrender value. Ask the insurer for the current figure in writing. You need it both to compare exits and to split the gain.
  4. Ordinary portion. Cash surrender value minus basis, if positive, capped at your total gain.
  5. Capital portion. Total gain minus the ordinary portion.
  6. Exclusion check. If the insured is terminally or chronically ill and the buyer qualifies as a viatical settlement provider, the exclusion described next may apply instead, and the lines above may not be needed.

When sale proceeds are tax free: the viatical exclusion

IRS Publication 525 (2025 edition, checked October 30, 2026) explains that amounts paid as accelerated death benefits "under a life insurance contract or viatical settlement" before the insured's death are excluded from income if the insured is terminally or chronically ill. A viatical settlement in this sense is "the sale or assignment of any part of the death benefit" to a viatical settlement provider, which is a person regularly in the business of buying such contracts on terminally or chronically ill insureds who meets the requirements of section 101(g)(2)(B).

The definitions carry the weight. A terminally ill individual is one certified by a physician as having an illness or condition "that can reasonably be expected to result in death within 24 months" of the certification, and for that person the exclusion is full. For a chronically ill individual who is not terminally ill, amounts paid for qualified long-term care costs are fully excludable, while per diem or periodic payments are excludable only up to a limit, which Publication 525 gives as $420 a day for 2025, shared with any periodic long-term care insurance payments. The 2026 limit is $430 a day, and the arithmetic for an insurer's own rider is worked in our accelerated death benefit rider guide. The exclusion does not reach payments to a business that holds the policy because the insured is its director, officer or employee or has a financial interest in it.

Two practical points follow. The physician certification and the buyer's status are documents to collect before closing, not after, because they decide which tax column applies. And a seller who could take an accelerated death benefit from the insurer under the same exclusion should compare the two directly: Washington's law already says a settlement must beat the accelerated benefit available, but the size of that margin, after fees, is the number that matters. Our guide to when life insurance is taxable covers the buyer's side of the same rules, including the transfer-for-value limit that applies when the buyer later collects.

What state law makes the buyer and broker tell you

Settlement rules are state law, and they differ. Washington's chapter 48.102 RCW is used here because it is a complete, current statute that a reader can check line by line. New York's booklet and the NAIC brochure cover much of the same ground. If you live elsewhere, ask your state insurance department for its rules; the NAIC brochure says your department "may regulate the purchase of life settlements" and can provide a copy of those regulations.

Checklist of disclosures under Washington law

RCW 48.102.080 requires the provider or broker to give the owner these facts no later than the date of application, among others:

  • That alternatives to a settlement exist, "including, but not limited to, accelerated benefits offered by the issuer."
  • That some or all of the proceeds "may be taxable" and that a tax advisor should be consulted.
  • That the proceeds "could be subject to the claims of creditors."
  • That receiving proceeds may affect eligibility for public assistance or other government benefits, and that advice should come from the agencies concerned.
  • That the owner may terminate the contract within fifteen days, on the terms described in the next section.
  • That proceeds will be sent within three business days after the provider receives the insurer's acknowledgment of the ownership transfer.
  • That a settlement "may cause other rights or benefits, including conversion rights and waiver of premium benefits," to be forfeited.
  • That the insured may be contacted to determine health status or verify address, limited to "once every three months" if life expectancy is more than one year and "no more than once per month" if it is one year or less.
  • That a broker "represents exclusively the owner" and owes the owner a fiduciary duty.
  • The name and contact details of the independent escrow agent, and the owner's right to see the escrow documents.
  • That a change of ownership could limit the insured's ability to buy more insurance later, "because there is a limit to how much coverage insurers will issue on one life."

The broker's own disclosures, due no later than signing, include a description of all offers, counter-offers, acceptances and rejections, any affiliation with a bidder, the name of each broker paid and the amount received, and the gross-to-net reconciliation mentioned in the worksheet. RCW 48.102.110 adds that a broker's fee must be "computed as a percentage of the offer obtained, not the face value of the policy." New York's booklet likewise says the broker must disclose its compensation no later than the date the contract is signed.

The fifteen-day rescission right and the escrow

Under RCW 48.102.110, every Washington settlement contract must let the owner rescind "on or before fifteen days after the date it is executed by all parties." Rescission works only if the owner gives notice and repays "all proceeds and any premiums, loans, and loan interest paid on account of the provider" inside that period. If the insured dies during the window, the contract is treated as rescinded, subject to the same repayment by the owner or the estate. If the owner was never given written notice of the right, the right stays open until thirty days after the notice is given.

New York measures its window differently: its booklet says you may rescind "from the day it is signed until fifteen days after you receive the proceeds." The NAIC brochure, written for all states, says only that in many states the owner may change their mind "for a certain period of time" and must return the money and the premiums the buyer paid. The lesson is to read your own contract's rescission clause and calendar the last day.

The money itself moves through escrow. Washington requires the provider, within three business days of receiving the owner's transfer documents, to pay the proceeds into an escrow or trust account at a state or federally chartered financial institution, and the escrow agent must release them to the owner within three business days after the insurer acknowledges the transfer. If the proceeds are not tendered by the disclosed date, the contract becomes voidable by the owner. The NAIC brochure gives the same advice in consumer terms: make sure the provider agrees to put proceeds "in escrow with an independent party or financial institution."

The two-year bar on newer policies

RCW 48.102.110 also bars settling a policy during the two years after it was issued, with listed exceptions. They include a policy issued on conversion where the time under the old and new policy together is at least twenty-four months; and, during the two years, the owner or insured becoming terminally or chronically ill, the death of the owner's spouse, divorce, retirement from full-time employment, a disability that prevents full-time work, the owner leaving a closely held business under a buyout agreement in effect when the policy was issued, or a court order adjudicating the owner bankrupt or insolvent. The rule exists to stop people buying policies in order to sell them. The NAIC brochure warns that if "someone wants you to buy a policy and then sell it immediately," you should contact your state insurance department, and New York's booklet names this stranger-originated life insurance, or STOLI, and says New York law prohibits it.

Policies and owners that complicate a sale

The worksheet and the Washington checklist assume an individually owned policy, an owner who is also the insured, and nobody else with a claim on the coverage. Seven situations change that picture.

  • Term policies. A term policy has no cash value, so the surrender column is zero, but it is still property that can be sold; the IRS's own Situation 3 involves exactly that sale. Whether any provider wants a particular term policy is not something this page can predict. If the term is convertible, the conversion right may matter to a buyer and to you, and Washington's disclosure warns that a sale can forfeit conversion rights. Read how term conversion works before deciding a term policy is worth nothing, and see the five exits from an ending term policy if the term is close to its end date anyway.
  • Coverage through work. Group certificates are owned and administered under the employer's plan. The NAIC brochure lists "Is my policy an employer or other group policy? If so, do I need their permission to sell it?" among the questions to ask, and New York's booklet asks whether a group policy allows a sale at all. Get the plan's answer in writing before any application.
  • Medicaid and SSI. A lump sum can push a household above means-tested limits. The NAIC brochure warns sellers to find out if they will lose benefits "such as food stamps or Medicaid," and New York's booklet names supplementary Social Security, food stamps and Medicaid. The policy's cash value may already count as a resource before any sale; life insurance and Medicaid eligibility explains how face value and cash value are tested. Ask the benefits agency, not the buyer.
  • Creditors. Whatever protection your state's law gives the policy itself, cash from a sale is a different asset. Both Washington's disclosures and the NAIC brochure say proceeds could be claimed by creditors. If debts are the reason for selling, a lawyer's view on exemptions comes first.
  • A divorce decree or business agreement. If a court order or buy-sell agreement requires the policy to stay in force for someone, selling it can breach that obligation. Read the order before you list the policy.
  • Privacy that lasts as long as you do. The seller shares medical and personal information, and the NAIC brochure warns that third parties "may sell your policy and pass along your medical and personal information to other individuals." Washington caps routine contact at once every three months while life expectancy exceeds one year, and New York's booklet sets the same limits. Contact continues for the rest of the insured's life, possibly from a later owner.
  • The insured is not the owner. When an adult child owns a policy on a parent, or a trust owns it, the owner sells but the insured's records and consent are needed. Washington requires, for a terminally or chronically ill insured, the insured's consent to release medical records and, if the owner is the insured, a physician's statement that the owner is of sound mind and under no undue influence.

From the first call to escrow, in order

StepWhat to collectWhy it comes at this point
1. Ask the insurerCash surrender value, cost basis, loan balance, accelerated benefit terms, reduced face options, all in writingThese set the floor any settlement must beat and the figures for the tax worksheet
2. Re-test the needWho depends on the death benefit today, and whether any decree or agreement requires the policyA sale removes the benefit for good
3. Check benefits and creditorsA written answer from any benefits agency involved, and legal advice if debts are pressingCash can cost more in lost benefits or exposed assets than it brings in
4. Check licencesProvider and broker licence status from your state insurance departmentWashington licenses both under RCW 48.102.011 and 48.102.021, and your state department can confirm its own rules
5. Collect offersEvery offer and counter-offer, the gross-to-net reconciliation, and the broker's compensationThe net figure is the only one to compare with step 1
6. Run the tax worksheetYour figures in the six lines above, reviewed by a tax professionalThe after-tax result decides whether the sale beats surrender or an accelerated benefit
7. Close with protections in placeEscrow agent details, the rescission deadline, and copies of everything signedThese are the rights you can still use after signing

If the answer at step 2 is that coverage is still needed, the question changes from how to sell to how to afford what you have. A smaller face amount or a lower-cost replacement may solve the premium problem without giving up the benefit. Line up any replacement quotes on one basis in the quote worksheet, which computes total paid and cost per $1,000 from the figures you enter. It stores nothing and sends nothing. The buying and cost mechanics hub collects the rest of our guides on pricing, term length and what to do when a policy ends.

Seven ways sellers end up with less

  1. Not asking the insurer first. The cash surrender value, loan options, a reduced face amount and any accelerated benefit are all inside the contract and cost nothing to ask about. Washington even requires insurers to notify owners whose insured is 60 or older, or known to be terminally or chronically ill, that alternatives may exist when the owner asks to surrender, requests an accelerated benefit, or receives a lapse notice.
  2. Taking one offer. New Jersey's page tells sellers to review multiple bona fide bids. A broker's disclosure of every offer and counter-offer is the tool for checking that the bidding happened.
  3. Comparing the gross offer with surrender. Compare the net amount after broker compensation and costs, after tax, with the after-tax surrender value. On the IRS figures above, the pre-tax gap was $2,000.
  4. Letting the policy lapse while shopping. A settlement application takes time, and a lapsed policy has nothing to sell. Keep premiums paid until the transfer is acknowledged. Our grace period and reinstatement guide explains how much time a missed premium leaves.
  5. Selling cover the family still needs. The NAIC brochure's first follow-up question is "Do I still need life insurance protection?" and its second is "Will I qualify for a new life insurance policy in the future?" A sale is permanent, and replacement cover at an older age may be unavailable or expensive. Our guide to dropping life insurance in retirement walks through whether the need has really ended.
  6. Answering medical questions loosely. The NAIC brochure says applications must be accurate and truthful, especially about medical history. Washington requires a separate signed fraud warning on settlement applications.
  7. Missing the rescission deadline. The window is short, and using it requires repaying everything, including premiums the buyer paid. Decide with the money in escrow, not after it is spent.

This page explains how life settlements work and how to compare them with other exits on arithmetic and law. Education only. This site does not sell insurance and does not provide quotes. It does not predict whether any buyer will bid on a policy, or what a bid would be. State settlement laws, your contract and federal tax rules control, and a licensed life insurance agent, a tax professional and your state insurance department are the right next contacts for a decision about your own policy.

Before any broker is involved, send one written request to your insurer, with no sale attached. Ask for the cash surrender value, your cost basis and the accelerated benefit terms. Those three figures are the floor every offer has to clear, and you need them whether you sell, surrender or keep the policy. If a premium increase is what started this, read how whole life cash value is built or the universal life guide linked above, to see whether the policy itself offers a lower-cost way to keep some coverage.

Sources

Before you sell: common questions

Can I sell my life insurance policy for cash?

Often, yes, if you own the policy and a licensed buyer wants it. The sale is called a life settlement, or a viatical settlement if the insured is terminally or chronically ill. The buyer pays a lump sum, takes over the premiums and collects the death benefit. Some policies receive no bid, and nothing obliges you to accept an offer. Some states restrict sales in the first two years after issue; Washington does, with exceptions such as serious illness, divorce or retirement.

How much will I get if I sell my life insurance policy?

No public source can tell you, and this site does not estimate offers. In Washington, the law defines a life settlement as paying less than the expected death benefit and more than the cash surrender value or accelerated benefit available. Where an offer lands in that range depends on the buyer's estimate of the insured's life expectancy, the premiums it expects to pay and its costs. Compare the net offer after broker compensation with the after-tax surrender value.

Is money from a life settlement taxable?

It can be. IRS Publication 525 excludes viatical settlement proceeds when the insured is terminally ill, and within limits when the insured is chronically ill. Otherwise a sale is taxable: under Rev. Rul. 2009-13 as modified by Rev. Rul. 2020-5, gain up to the cash surrender value minus premiums paid is ordinary income and any gain above that is capital gain. The buyer reports the purchase on Form 1099-LS. A tax professional should review your figures.

Can I change my mind after selling my policy?

In many states, for a short time. Washington lets the owner rescind on or before fifteen days after the contract is signed by all parties, and New York until fifteen days after the proceeds are received. In both cases you must repay the proceeds and the premiums the buyer paid. Check the rescission clause in your own contract and put the last day on a calendar.

Will the buyer keep contacting me after the sale?

Yes, the buyer or its representative may contact the insured to check health status or address for as long as the insured lives. Washington and New York limit routine contact to once every three months if life expectancy is more than one year, and once a month if it is one year or less. The policy, and your information, may also be resold to other buyers.

Is selling better than surrendering my policy?

Only if the net amount after fees and tax beats the after-tax surrender value by enough to justify sharing medical information and giving up any chance of the benefit reaching your family. In the IRS example in Rev. Rul. 2009-13, surrender paid $78,000 and a sale paid $80,000 on a policy with $64,000 of premiums paid. Ask the insurer about loans, a reduced death benefit and any accelerated benefit before deciding.