Skip to main content

Buying by age

Surrendering a Life Insurance Policy: Does It Raise Medicare Premiums or Social Security Tax?

Buying by age · Updated November 4, 2026

Yes, when the surrender produces a taxable gain. That gain goes into adjusted gross income, and adjusted gross income sets both the Medicare Part B and Part D income-related surcharge (a cliff, billed two years later) and how much of a Social Security benefit is taxed (a ramp that stops at 85 percent). A surrender that returns no more than the investment in the contract (generally the premiums paid) adds nothing to either test.

The cliff is the expensive part. On the 2026 CMS schedule, a single filer whose Medicare income lands $1 above $109,000 pays $81.20 more a month for Part B and $14.50 more for Part D, which is $1,148.40 over a twelve-month year, while the same income at exactly $109,000 pays nothing extra. The Social Security test has no cliff: its base amount of $25,000 and adjusted base amount of $34,000 for a single filer are written into the statute with no inflation clause, and each added dollar of income moves the taxable share up gradually until 85 percent of the benefit is taxed.

Sources and dates: how we check each figure.

What a surrender adds to income

A policy surrendered for cash is taxed under section 72(e) of the Internal Revenue Code, in the version on the Office of the Law Revision Counsel site, current through Public Law 119-136 of October 22, 2026. Paragraph (5)(E) sends a full surrender into the cost-recovery rule: "This paragraph shall apply to (i) any amount received, whether in a single sum or otherwise, under a contract in full discharge of the obligation under the contract which is in the nature of a refund of the consideration paid for the contract, and (ii) any amount received under a contract on its complete surrender, redemption, or maturity. In the case of any amount to which the preceding sentence applies, the rule of paragraph (2)(A) shall not apply." Paragraph (5)(A) then says the amount "shall be included in gross income, but only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract." Paragraph (6) defines that investment as the premiums paid, minus amounts received earlier that were excluded from income.

Take an invented policy. The owner paid $61,000 of premiums over the years, never took a tax-free withdrawal, and surrenders for $85,000. The gain is $85,000 minus $61,000, which is $24,000, and only that $24,000 enters adjusted gross income. If the insurer also repays a $25,000 policy loan out of the cash value, the owner receives a check for $60,000 but the gain is still $24,000, because the loan payoff counts as received. The loan version of this arithmetic, including the case where the loan has grown past the premiums, is worked in what happens to a policy loan when the policy lapses, and the choice between surrender and sale is in selling a life insurance policy. Neither is repeated here. A sale to a settlement buyer is taxed under different rules from a surrender, so the section 72(e) arithmetic in this guide is for surrenders; a taxable gain from either route still lands in adjusted gross income and meets the same two tests.

The IRS instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 (2026 edition) tell insurers that they "do not need to file Form 1099-R to report the surrender of a life insurance contract if it is reasonable to believe that none of the payment is includible in the income of the recipient," and point to distribution code 7 for the surrenders they do report. A policy that returns less than the premiums paid may therefore produce no form at all, and a policy with a gain is reported on a form whose taxable amount flows into the return.

The return is where the two tests below pick it up. IRS Publication 915 (2025 edition) builds the Social Security worksheet from Form 1040 lines 1z, 2b, 3b, 4b, 5b, 7a and 8, and the worksheet has no separate line for life insurance. A gain reported anywhere on the return that those lines collect is counted. The Medicare test starts from adjusted gross income itself, so it does not depend on which line carries the gain.

How the Medicare surcharge is set

Section 1839(i) of the Social Security Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 1395r(i), creates the Part B surcharge. Paragraph (1) reads: "In the case of an individual whose modified adjusted gross income exceeds the threshold amount under paragraph (2), the monthly amount of the premium subsidy applicable to the premium under this section for a month after December 2006 shall be reduced (and the monthly premium shall be increased) by the monthly adjustment amount specified in paragraph (3)." Paragraph (4)(A) defines the income measure: "the term 'modified adjusted gross income' means adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) (i) determined without regard to sections 135, 911, 931, and 933 of such Code; and (ii) increased by the amount of interest received or accrued during the taxable year which is exempt from tax under such Code. In the case of an individual filing a joint return, any reference in this subsection to the modified adjusted gross income of such individual shall be to such return's modified adjusted gross income."

The Social Security Administration's regulation at 20 CFR 418.1010(b)(6) restates it for Part B: modified adjusted gross income "is your adjusted gross income as defined by the Internal Revenue Code, plus the following forms of tax-exempt income," followed by tax-exempt interest, U.S. savings bond interest used for higher education, foreign earned income, and income from Guam, American Samoa, the Northern Mariana Islands and Puerto Rico. A life insurance gain is not on that list because it does not need to be: it is already in adjusted gross income.

Part D follows the same income test. Section 1860D-13(a)(7), at 42 U.S.C. 1395w-113(a)(7), applies the Part D surcharge to a person whose modified adjusted gross income exceeds the same threshold under section 1395r(i)(2), and defines that income by pointing back to the Part B definition for the taxable year chosen under the same lookback rules. The Part D surcharge is paid in addition to the drug plan's own premium. Under 20 CFR 418.2112(a), the Administration "will deduct the income-related monthly adjustment amount from your Social Security benefits if they are sufficient to cover the amount owed," and if they are not, CMS bills the full amount.

The 2026 schedule, as CMS published it

CMS released the 2026 Part A and Part B amounts and the 2026 Part D surcharges on November 14, 2025, and the Part B notice (CMS-8091-N) ran in the Federal Register on November 19, 2025. The table repeats those published surcharge amounts; the right-hand column is the two Medicare amounts multiplied by twelve, computed for this guide. These are Medicare charges. They are not life insurance premiums, and nothing in the table prices a policy.

Individual-return MAGI (single, head of household and similar; 2026 schedule)Joint filers MAGIPart B surcharge per monthPart D surcharge per monthBoth, twelve months
$109,000 or less$218,000 or less$0.00$0.00$0.00
Over $109,000 to $137,000Over $218,000 to $274,000$81.20$14.50$1,148.40
Over $137,000 to $171,000Over $274,000 to $342,000$202.90$37.50$2,884.80
Over $171,000 to $205,000Over $342,000 to $410,000$324.60$60.40$4,620.00
Over $205,000, under $500,000Over $410,000, under $750,000$446.30$83.30$6,355.20
$500,000 or more$750,000 or more$487.00$91.00$6,936.00

The Part B surcharge is added to the standard 2026 premium of $202.90, so the first tier pays a total of $284.10 a month and the top tier $689.90, according to the same notice. A married person who lived with a spouse at any time during the year but files a separate return has only two bands: over $109,000 and under $391,000 pays a $446.30 Part B surcharge and an $83.30 Part D surcharge, and $391,000 or more pays $487.00 and $91.00. The first of those bands starts at the same $109,000 as everyone else's first tier. Crossing it costs $6,355.20 a year for the two parts together, which is the fourth-tier amount in the table above.

The statute puts a surcharge on "an individual," and the joint-return sentence in paragraph (4)(A) changes only whose income is measured. In the writer's reading, each spouse enrolled in Part B pays the surcharge, so a married couple with both spouses enrolled and joint income just over $218,000 would pay the first-tier amounts twice, $2,296.80 for the year for both parts. The notice's own wording for the filing groups is "beneficiaries who file joint tax returns," and a spouse's actual bill depends on that spouse's enrollment.

Which year's premium a surrender hits

The surcharge does not follow the year of the surrender. The statute, paragraph (4)(B)(i), says: "In applying this subsection for an individual's premiums in a month in a year, subject to clause (ii) and subparagraph (C), the individual's modified adjusted gross income shall be such income determined for the individual's last taxable year beginning in the second calendar year preceding the year involved." The regulation says the same thing in plainer terms at 20 CFR 418.1135(a): "In general, we will use your modified adjusted gross income provided by IRS for the tax year 2 years prior to the effective year of the income-related monthly adjustment amount determination. Modified adjusted gross income is based on information you provide to IRS when you file your Federal income tax return."

Surrender received in tax yearPremium year it can raiseYear SSA uses first if IRS data for the surrender year are missing
202520272024
202620282025
202720292026

The third column comes from 418.1135(b), which allows the Administration to use the tax year three years before the premium year "when IRS does not provide the information specified in paragraph (a)." Section 418.1110(b) then provides that when the later year's data arrive, "the effective date of the new initial determination will be January 1 of the effective year, or the first month you were enrolled or re-enrolled in Medicare Part B if later than January." A surcharge that was not in the January bill can therefore arrive mid-year with a retroactive adjustment back to January. The arithmetic for that catch-up is the monthly amount times the months already passed, plus the same amount each month after.

Three practical consequences follow from the table. A surrender in November 2026 has no effect on the 2027 Part B premium, because that premium rests on 2025 income. The amount received in 2026 sets the 2028 premium. It can also appear temporarily in a 2029 determination, because 418.1135(b) lets the Administration use the tax year three years back when the IRS data for the later year are missing, as the table's third column shows; the correction then runs back to January 1. And moving the payment across a year boundary moves which premium year pays the surcharge: money received on December 30, 2026 lands in tax year 2026 and raises 2028, while money received in January 2027 lands in tax year 2027 and raises 2029. Section 72(e)(1)(A) reaches an amount that "is received under an annuity, endowment, or life insurance contract," so the year of receipt, not the year of the decision, is the year that counts. Under 26 CFR 1.451-2(a), income is also treated as received in the year it is "credited to his account, set apart for him, or otherwise made available so that he may draw upon it at any time," so the date the funds are made available, not only the date a check is cashed, is what to confirm with the insurer.

Whatever the 2028 thresholds turn out to be, they are not known today. The statute indexes the thresholds for inflation, and its paragraph (5)(C)(ii) starts indexing the $500,000 amounts only "in the case of any calendar year beginning after 2027," measured against the average of the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers for the twelve months ending August 2026. The regulation says the same in its own words at 418.1115(e)(2). That makes 2028 the first year in which the top bands move, and every Medicare dollar figure in the worked examples is the 2026 schedule applied as an illustration, not a prediction for the year a 2026 surrender would be billed.

One dollar over the line

The CMS table labels its first band "greater than $109,000." Income of exactly $109,000 pays no surcharge, and income of $109,001 pays the full first-tier amount for every month of the premium year in which the person is enrolled, a rule stated in 20 CFR 418.1110(a).

The table below shows what each crossing adds on the 2026 amounts. The step column is the added cost of moving up one band, computed by subtracting the row above.

Single MAGI crossesJoint MAGI crossesPart B per yearPart D per yearBoth per yearAdded by this crossing
$109,000$218,000$974.40$174.00$1,148.40$1,148.40
$137,000$274,000$2,434.80$450.00$2,884.80$1,736.40
$171,000$342,000$3,895.20$724.80$4,620.00$1,735.20
$205,000$410,000$5,355.60$999.60$6,355.20$1,735.20
$500,000$750,000$5,844.00$1,092.00$6,936.00$580.80

Three crossings add between $1,735.20 and $1,736.40 a year, the first adds $1,148.40, and the last adds $580.80. For a surrender gain that pushes a single filer $500 over $109,000, the surcharge is $1,148.40, which is 2.30 times the $500 that caused it. At $1,000 over, the multiple is 1.15. The ordinary income tax on those same dollars is a small fraction of either figure. The practical question for a surrender is therefore not the average cost of the gain but the distance between the income already expected for the lookback year and the next line.

That distance is simple to compute. Subtract expected adjusted gross income, before the gain, from the threshold. A gain no larger than the difference stays under the line, and one dollar more crosses it. The wrinkle, covered in the benefit-tax sections below, is that for someone below the 85 percent ceiling the gain also makes more Social Security taxable, so the adjusted gross income that matters is the gain plus the extra taxable benefits it triggers, not the gain alone.

How Social Security benefits get taxed

Section 86 of the Internal Revenue Code (on the Law Revision Counsel site; its amendment notes show the base amounts in subsection (c) as they stood after Public Law 103-66 of 1993, and the newest note, from 2021, changed only the list of excluded items in (b)(2)(A)) taxes benefits in two steps. First the test: paragraph (b)(1) says a taxpayer is described if "(A) the sum of (i) the modified adjusted gross income of the taxpayer for the taxable year, plus (ii) one-half of the social security benefits received during the taxable year, exceeds (B) the base amount." The measure of income here is its own definition in (b)(2): "adjusted gross income (A) determined without regard to this section and sections 85(c), 135, 137, 221, 911, 931, and 933, and (B) increased by the amount of interest received or accrued by the taxpayer during the taxable year which is exempt from tax." It is close to the Medicare measure but not identical, so the two tests can disagree on edge items such as education loan interest.

The base amounts are in subsection (c): "(1) Base amount. The term 'base amount' means (A) except as otherwise provided in this paragraph, $25,000, (B) $32,000 in the case of a joint return, and (C) zero in the case of a taxpayer who (i) is married as of the close of the taxable year (within the meaning of section 7703) but does not file a joint return for such year, and (ii) does not live apart from his spouse at all times during the taxable year." The adjusted base amounts are $34,000, $44,000 and zero on the same pattern. Publication 915 (2025 edition) restates them as the "base amount" of $25,000 for a single filer and $32,000 for a joint return, and the 85 percent rule as applying when the total "is more than $34,000 ($44,000 if you are married filing jointly)." Nothing in the text of section 86 adjusts any of these amounts for inflation.

Then the amount included. Paragraph (a)(1) gives the first tier: gross income includes "social security benefits in an amount equal to the lesser of (A) one-half of the social security benefits received during the taxable year, or (B) one-half of the excess described in subsection (b)(1)." Paragraph (a)(2), when the test total exceeds the adjusted base amount, takes the lesser of "(A) the sum of (i) 85 percent of such excess, plus (ii) the lesser of the amount determined under paragraph (1) or an amount equal to one-half of the difference between the adjusted base amount and the base amount of the taxpayer, or (B) 85 percent of the social security benefits received during the taxable year." The IRS worksheet in the publication (Worksheet 1) carries out the same steps. The formula reproduces three of the publication's own examples exactly: a single filer with $5,980 of benefits and $28,990 of other income has $2,990 taxable; a joint couple with $10,000 of benefits and $40,500 of other income has $6,275 taxable; and a married person filing separately who lived with a spouse, with $4,000 of benefits, has $3,400 taxable.

Two features matter for a surrender. Between the base amount and the adjusted base amount, each dollar of added income makes 50 cents of benefits taxable, so the dollar counts as $1.50 of adjusted gross income. Above the adjusted base amount, each dollar makes 85 cents of benefits taxable until the 85 percent ceiling, so the dollar counts as $1.85. After the ceiling, a dollar of gain counts once. The ceiling is a ceiling on the share of the benefit, not on income.

A surrender gain on the benefit worksheet

Take an invented single filer, age 66, with $24,000 of net Social Security benefits (box 5 of Form SSA-1099) and $20,000 of other income from a pension and interest, with no tax-exempt interest. Before any surrender, the test total is $20,000 plus half the benefits, $12,000, for $32,000. That is above the $25,000 base amount and below $34,000, so taxable benefits are half of the $7,000 excess, or $3,500. The table adds a surrender gain in steps.

Surrender gainTest total (other income + gain + half of benefits)Taxable benefitsShare of benefits taxedAdjusted gross incomeAGI added by the gain and the extra taxable benefits
$0$32,000$3,50014.6%$23,500$0
$2,000$34,000$4,50018.8%$26,500$3,000
$5,000$37,000$7,05029.4%$32,050$8,550
$10,000$42,000$11,30047.1%$41,300$17,800
$20,000$52,000$19,80082.5%$59,800$36,300
$30,000$62,000$20,40085.0%$70,400$46,900
$40,000$72,000$20,40085.0%$80,400$56,900

The first $2,000 of gain brings the test total to the $34,000 adjusted base amount and adds $1,000 of taxable benefits, so each dollar of that stretch counts as $1.50. Past $34,000, each dollar counts as $1.85, and that holds until the gain reaches about $20,706, where taxable benefits hit the 85 percent ceiling of $20,400. The $10,000 gain adds $17,800 to adjusted gross income, and the $20,000 gain adds $36,300. Between a $20,000 gain and a $30,000 gain, only $10,600 more adjusted gross income appears: the first $706 of that stretch still counts at $1.85, and every dollar after it counts once. By $30,000 the ramp is over; the gain of $40,000 adds $56,900, which is the $40,000 plus the full $16,900 of extra taxable benefits.

Nothing in this household reaches the Medicare line. The largest adjusted gross income in the table is $80,400, which is under $109,000, so the cost is all in the tax return. The other direction is a household whose benefits are already taxed at the 85 percent ceiling before the surrender. Take a single filer with $30,000 of benefits and $55,000 of other income. The test total is $70,000, the 85 percent rule gives $35,100, and the ceiling of $25,500 (85 percent of $30,000) is the lower number, so $25,500 is taxable and adjusted gross income is $80,500. A surrender gain adds only itself to adjusted gross income, since no further benefit can become taxable. This household's distance to $109,000 is exactly $28,500.

The over-65 deduction shrinks as well

A third effect is easy to miss. Section 151(d)(5)(C), added by Public Law 119-21, allows a deduction for seniors: "In the case of a taxable year beginning before January 1, 2029, there shall be allowed a deduction in an amount equal to $6,000 for each qualified individual with respect to the taxpayer." A qualified individual is the taxpayer if age 65 or older before the close of the year, and on a joint return the spouse on the same test. Clause (iii)(I) then says: "In the case of any taxpayer for any taxable year, the $6,000 amount in clause (i) shall be reduced (but not below zero) by 6 percent of so much of the taxpayer's modified adjusted gross income as exceeds $75,000 ($150,000 in the case of a joint return)." Clause (iii)(II) defines that income as "the adjusted gross income of the taxpayer for the taxable year increased by any amount excluded from gross income under section 911, 931, or 933."

The deduction is therefore a phase-out of six cents per dollar of income above $75,000 for a single filer. A surrender gain that falls in the phase-out takes six cents of deduction from each dollar, and the lost deduction is taxed at the filer's bracket. At a hypothetical 22 percent bracket, that is 1.32 cents of added tax per dollar of gain. For one qualified individual the deduction runs out at $175,000 of income, because $6,000 divided by 0.06 is $100,000. The household with $80,500 of adjusted gross income before the surrender has a deduction of $5,670. A $30,000 gain brings income to $110,500 and the deduction to $3,870, a loss of $1,800.

Section 62, which lists the deductions allowed in arriving at adjusted gross income, does not mention section 151, and the senior deduction's own text starts from adjusted gross income. In the writer's reading the deduction therefore sits below the adjusted gross income line and cannot lower the figure that the Medicare and Social Security tests use. The deduction applies to taxable years beginning before 2029, so a surrender received in 2029 or later would not have this third effect under the law as it now reads.

One gain, four effects added up

The four things that happen to a surrender gain are the ordinary income tax on the gain, the tax on newly taxable Social Security, the loss of the senior deduction, and the Medicare surcharge two years later. The table runs the household with $30,000 of benefits and $55,000 of other income through them at a hypothetical 22 percent marginal bracket, which is an assumption rather than a computation of anyone's return, and with the 2026 first-tier Medicare amounts. This household's benefits are already taxed at the 85 percent ceiling, so the column for newly taxable benefits is zero. State income tax is left out. The first row sits at the top of the headroom, the second a dollar past it.

Surrender gainAdjusted gross incomeTax at 22% on the gainTax on newly taxable benefitsTax on lost senior deductionMedicare surcharge, one yearTotalTotal as share of gain
$10,000$90,500$2,200.00$0.00$132.00$0.00$2,332.0023.3%
$28,500$109,000$6,270.00$0.00$376.20$0.00$6,646.2023.3%
$28,501$109,001$6,270.22$0.00$376.21$1,148.40$7,794.8327.3%
$30,000$110,500$6,600.00$0.00$396.00$1,148.40$8,144.4027.1%
$40,000$120,500$8,800.00$0.00$528.00$1,148.40$10,476.4026.2%

The one dollar between $28,500 and $28,501 of gain adds $1,148.63 to the total. Going from a $28,500 gain to a $30,000 gain, which is $1,500 more income, adds $1,498.20 of cost, or 99.9 percent of the extra gain. A person in that range who had planned to take the money whole would be keeping almost none of the last $1,500. Splitting the money over two tax years does not by itself split the gain. In the writer's reading of paragraph (5)(A), a first receipt within the premiums paid is excluded and leaves the whole gain for the later receipt, so a split moves gain into the earlier year only when the first receipt exceeds the investment in the contract. Whether a contract allows a partial surrender, and whether a modified endowment contract or a benefit reduction within 15 years changes the order, is a question for the policy and a tax professional.

The surcharge in the table is a one-year cost: the surrender year sets one premium year, 2028 for a 2026 receipt, plus the temporary 2029 fallback described above. A later premium year pays a surcharge only if its own lookback income is also over a line.

Money that never reaches the return

The arithmetic above applies to the taxable gain only. Several ways of getting money out of, or out of the way of, a policy do not put a gain in adjusted gross income, and each one has conditions that decide whether it works.

  • The death benefit. Section 101(a)(1): "Except as otherwise provided in paragraphs (2) and (3), subsection (d), subsection (f), and subsection (j), gross income does not include amounts received (whether in a single sum or otherwise) under a life insurance contract, if such amounts are paid by reason of the death of the insured." Paragraph (2) is the transfer-for-value rule, which matters for policies that were sold. A beneficiary's lump sum is outside both tests unless one of those exceptions applies, and interest earned on installment payouts is covered in is life insurance taxable.
  • Withdrawals from an ordinary policy. Section 72(e)(5)(C) reads: "Except as provided in paragraph (10) and except to the extent prescribed by the Secretary by regulations, this paragraph shall apply to any amount not received as an annuity which is received under a life insurance or endowment contract." Read with paragraph (5)(A), which includes an amount in gross income "only to the extent it exceeds the investment in the contract," a withdrawal of up to the premiums paid is, in the writer's reading, not included for a contract the paragraph covers. Section 7702(f)(7) has separate rules for benefit reductions in the first 15 years of a policy, under headings "Rule for certain changes during first 15 years" and "Treatment of certain distributions made in anticipation of benefit reductions," and the insurer's tax reporting answers whether they apply.
  • Policy loans. The same paragraph (5)(A)(i) says "paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) shall not apply," and (4)(A) is the rule that treats a loan as a distribution. In the writer's reading, a loan from a policy that falls under paragraph (5) is not itself a taxable receipt, and the tax shows up only if the policy later lapses or is surrendered with the loan outstanding. That later event is the subject of the lapse guide.
  • Modified endowment contracts. Section 72(e)(10)(A) reverses the order: "Notwithstanding paragraph (5)(C), in the case of any modified endowment contract (as defined in section 7702A) (i) paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) shall apply, and (ii) in applying paragraph (4)(A), 'any person' shall be substituted for 'an individual'." Paragraph (2)(B) includes amounts in income first "to the extent allocable to income on the contract," so a withdrawal or loan from such a contract can push income up before any premiums come back. Paragraph (10)(B) carves out one narrow case, an assignment solely to cover burial expenses on a contract with a maximum death benefit of $25,000 or less. How a policy becomes one is in the seven-pay test guide.
  • An exchange. Section 1035(a)(1): "No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract." The exchange moves the gain into the new contract rather than removing it, and later withdrawals from the new contract are taxed under the rules for that contract. The replacement rules and the reverse-direction trap are in replacing a life insurance policy.

Which of these rules applies depends on the policy's tax status and history. The insurer's gain computation and the policy file are the place to start, not the cash value printed on an annual statement.

What the appeal rules allow

The Administration can use a more recent year's income in place of the lookback year, but only for listed events. Section 418.1201 requires a major life-changing event that causes a significant reduction in income, a request, and evidence. Section 418.1205 lists the events: "(a) Your spouse dies; (b) You marry; (c) Your marriage ends through divorce or annulment; (d) You or your spouse stop working or reduce the hours you work; (e) You or your spouse experiences a loss of income-producing property, provided the loss is not at the direction of you or your spouse (e.g., due to the sale or transfer of the property) and is not a result of the ordinary risk of investment. Examples of the type of property loss include, but are not limited to: Loss of real property within a Presidentially or Gubernatorially-declared disaster area, destruction of livestock or crops by natural disaster or disease, loss from real property due to arson, or loss of investment property as a result of fraud or theft due to a criminal act by a third party; (f) You or your spouse experiences a scheduled cessation, termination, or reorganization of an employer's pension plan; (g) You or your spouse receives a settlement from an employer or former employer because of the employer's closure, bankruptcy, or reorganization."

Section 418.1210 closes the list: "We will not consider events other than those described in § 418.1205 to be major life-changing events." The surrender of a policy by its owner is not among the seven. The list does include a spouse who stops working, and a request based on that event can ask the Administration to use a later year in which the surrender gain does not appear. That is a request built on retirement, not on the surrender, and it works only if the later year's income is "significantly" lower under 418.1215, meaning low enough to reduce the percentage or eliminate the surcharge. Part D follows the same rules by cross-reference in 418.2205 and 418.2210.

Other routes are about errors. If the IRS gave the Administration wrong income information, 418.1335(a) says the IRS "will provide you with documentation of the error, such as a copy of your Federal income tax return," and "you will need to request that we use that information and provide us with the IRS documentation confirming the error." For an amended return, 418.1150 says: "You may provide your amended tax return for a tax year we used within 3 calendar years following the close of the tax year for which you filed the amended tax return." An initial determination can also be reconsidered under 418.1325, which sends the request through the ordinary Social Security review rules, and 418.1330 says a request that rests only on a claim that the IRS information was wrong will be dismissed in favor of the correction route. None of these routes changes a correct gain reported on a correct return.

A practical check sits before the appeal. The notice the Administration sends states, under 418.1315(b), "what modified adjusted gross income information we used to make our determination." Compare that figure with the return. In a surrender year, the comparison should include Form 1099-R, whose Box 2a is the taxable amount and whose Box 5 is where the form instructions put insurance premiums recoverable tax free.

What is published for 2027 so far

As of November 4, 2026, the newest published Part B and Part D surcharge schedule is the 2026 one, announced by CMS on November 14, 2025, with the Part B notice published in the Federal Register on November 19, 2025. The Federal Register shows no 2027 Part B premium notice, and a document titled "Medicare Program; Implementation of Sections 6219, 6220, and 6224 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026," published October 20, 2026, is a proposed rule about Part D cost-sharing reductions, provider lists and pharmacy benefit managers, with no surcharge content. The 2027 amounts are not used in this guide.

The regulation says CMS publishes threshold amounts in the Federal Register in September, in 20 CFR 418.1105(c), while the 2026 amounts appeared in the November notice. The dollar ranges printed in 418.1115 are the 2019 base amounts, and 418.1115(e) says CMS sets later ranges "by increasing the preceding year's ranges by any percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index rounded to the nearest $1,000." Readers should take every dollar figure from the current CMS notice, not from the regulation. Because of the lookback, none of the 2027 numbers can change the answer for a surrender received in 2026, whose premium year is 2028.

The same check covers the Social Security side. IRS Publication 915 (2025 edition, for 2025 returns) is the newest edition posted; the address for a 2026 edition returns a not-found page, and the publication itself says to see IRS.gov/Pub915 for later developments. Section 86's base amounts have the 1993 text described above, and its newest amendment note, from 2021, touches only the list of exclusions. Section 1395r, which holds the Part B surcharge, shows its newest amendment notes in 2022, in subsection (e), and its last notes touching subsection (i) are dated 2020 (a margin change and a formula point for people enrolled only for immunosuppressive drugs), after the 2018 change that added the $500,000 tier.

Documents to request before surrendering

Nothing here is tax, legal or financial advice or a prediction of any person's bill, and the site neither sells insurance nor provides quotes. A tax professional or the insurer can supply the policy-specific numbers; the requests below make the ask precise.

  1. What is the gain, in the insurer's records? Ask for the cash surrender value, any loan balance, the premiums paid and any amounts already received tax-free, so the investment in the contract can be checked against the policy file.
  2. Is the contract a modified endowment contract? The answer decides whether earlier withdrawals and loans were already taxable.
  3. In which tax year will the amount be received? The year decides the premium year, as the lookback table shows.
  4. What is the income expected for that year before the gain? Add the Social Security the gain would make taxable, using the publication's worksheet with and without the gain, and compare the result with the first Medicare line for the filing status.
  5. Who is enrolled in Medicare, and in which parts? The CMS table carries separate Part B and Part D amounts, so the enrollment of each spouse changes the total.
  6. Is a different exit available? Reduced paid-up and extended term options are compared in extended term versus reduced paid-up insurance, and the retirement trade-offs for ending coverage are in dropping life insurance in retirement.
  7. When will the payment be issued? The year of receipt is the year that counts, so ask for the issue date in writing before a year-end request.

Sources

Questions people ask about surrender gains, Medicare and Social Security

Does surrendering a life insurance policy raise Medicare premiums?

It can, if the surrender produces a taxable gain. The gain is part of adjusted gross income, and Medicare's income-related surcharge for Part B and Part D is set from adjusted gross income two years before the premium year. On the 2026 schedule the first band starts above $109,000 for a single filer, and the surcharge is $81.20 a month for Part B and $14.50 for Part D. A surrender with no gain adds nothing to the test.

Is the cash from a surrendered policy taxed as Social Security income?

No. Surrender proceeds are taxed, to the extent they exceed the investment in the contract, as income under section 72(e), not as Social Security. What the gain does is enter the income measure that decides how much of the Social Security benefit is taxable, using a base amount of $25,000 and an adjusted base amount of $34,000 for a single filer, and $32,000 and $44,000 for a joint return.

Which year's income does Medicare look at after a surrender?

Income from two years earlier. Under 20 CFR 418.1135(a), the Administration uses the modified adjusted gross income that the IRS provides for the tax year two years before the premium year. A surrender received in 2026 can therefore raise the 2028 premium, and 2027 is not affected. If IRS data for the surrender year are missing, the Administration first uses the tax year three years back and adjusts to January 1 once the later data arrive.

Can I appeal an income-related surcharge caused by a policy surrender?

Not on the ground of the surrender itself. The list of major life-changing events in 20 CFR 418.1205 does not include it, and 418.1210 says other events do not count. Relief exists for listed events such as a spouse's death, a divorce, or stopping or reducing work, when income in a later year falls enough to lower the band. Errors in the income data used have their own correction routes under 418.1150 and 418.1335.

Does taking a loan from the policy instead of surrendering it avoid both tests?

In the writer's reading of section 72(e)(5)(A)(i), which says "paragraphs (2)(B) and (4)(A) shall not apply," a loan from a policy that falls under section 72(e)(5) is not itself treated as a distribution, so no gain enters adjusted gross income when it is taken. The tax arrives if the policy later lapses or is surrendered with the loan outstanding, because the loan payoff is part of the amount received. A modified endowment contract follows the opposite order under 72(e)(10), so the same loan can be taxable immediately.

Are the 2027 Medicare surcharge amounts out yet?

Not as of November 4, 2026. The 2026 schedule was announced on November 14, 2025 and published in the Federal Register on November 19, 2025, and no 2027 Part B premium notice appeared in the Federal Register as of that date. A 2026 surrender is billed in 2028 in any case, so the 2027 figures would not change its result.