Policy types
Extended Term vs Reduced Paid-Up Insurance: The Same Cash Value Worked at Five Ages
Policy types compared · Updated November 3, 2026
Extended term insurance keeps the full death benefit in force for a limited time. Reduced paid-up insurance keeps a smaller death benefit for life. On an invented whole life policy with a $100,000 face amount and a $15,000 cash value at age 60, a 4 percent illustrative interest rate and the CDC's 2024 mortality table give either $35,584 of paid-up coverage or $100,000 of coverage for 15 years and 51 days.
Neither figure belongs to a real contract, and the gap between them is the point. Texas Insurance Code section 1105.004 requires a policy to offer a paid-up nonforfeiture benefit on request within 60 days, to pay a cash surrender value after three full years of premiums, and to name a default that takes effect if the owner elects nothing. It does not name extended term insurance as an option anywhere in that section. The menu is whatever the policy prints, so the same missed premium can end in a smaller policy for life or a term policy with an expiry date, depending on one page of the contract.
Sources and dates: how we check each figure.
One cash value, two different shapes
Both options start from the same number: the net cash value on the premium due date, meaning the cash value less any loan. The arithmetic treats that amount as a single premium and asks what it buys. Reduced paid-up insurance spends it on a whole life policy that never needs another premium, so the amount is whatever the money covers for the rest of the insured's life. Extended term insurance spends it on term coverage at the original face amount, so the period is whatever the money covers before it runs out. Cash and time trade against each other, and the same dollars cannot buy both a large amount and a long period.
The New York Department of Financial Services glossary defines the pieces in two entries, checked November 3, 2026. "Non-Forfeiture" is "One of the choices available if the policy owner discontinues premium payments on a policy with a cash value. Options available are to take the cash value in cash or to use it to purchase extended term insurance or reduced paid-up insurance." "Reduced Paid-up Insurance" is "A form of insurance available as a non-forfeiture option. It provides for continuation of the original insurance plan, but for a reduced amount, without further premiums." The glossary has no separate entry for extended term insurance, so in this guide the term means what the arithmetic below builds: the original face amount, no further premiums, for a period that the cash value pays for in advance.
Two equations carry the whole comparison. For reduced paid-up insurance, the paid-up amount equals the net cash value divided by the cost of one dollar of whole life coverage at the attained age. For extended term, the period is the number of years n at which the cost of one dollar of n-year term coverage, multiplied by the face amount, equals the net cash value. Each "cost" here is a present value: the chance of dying in each future year, multiplied by a discount factor for that year, added up. The two answers are equal in value at the moment of conversion by construction. They differ in who collects and when.
The mechanical consequence is that the longer an insured person is expected to live, the more of the cash value goes to the long tail of far-off deaths. A paid-up policy for a 40-year-old must be cheap per dollar of coverage, because most of its payout is decades away and discounted heavily, so the reduced paid-up amount stays large. For an 80-year-old, nearly every dollar of coverage is likely to be paid soon, so each dollar costs far more and the same cash value buys much less. The worked table further down shows exactly how steep that slope is.
What Texas Insurance Code 1105.004 requires
Texas Insurance Code chapter 1105 is titled the Standard Nonforfeiture Law for Life Insurance (section 1105.001). Section 1105.004 (checked November 3, 2026, on the Texas Legislature's statute site) lists what a life insurance policy delivered or issued for delivery in Texas must contain, "in substance", or "corresponding provisions" that the department finds at least as favorable to the policyholder. Three subsections matter for a lapsed premium.
Subsection (b) is the paid-up benefit: "A life insurance policy must provide that if there is a default in the payment of a premium the company, on proper request not later than the 60th day after the due date of the premium that is in default, will grant a paid-up nonforfeiture benefit on a plan stipulated in the policy, effective as of that due date, in the amount specified by this chapter." The next sentence lets a company "substitute for the paid-up nonforfeiture benefit required by this subsection an actuarially equivalent alternative paid-up nonforfeiture benefit that provides a greater amount or longer period of death benefits or, if applicable, a greater amount or earlier payment of endowment benefits." The sentence after that adds that to elect such an alternative, the person entitled to make the election must submit a proper request not later than the 60th day after the due date.
Subsection (c)(1) is the cash alternative: the policy must provide that on surrender not later than the 60th day after the due date of a premium in default, the company pays, "in lieu of a paid-up nonforfeiture benefit, a cash surrender value in the amount specified by this chapter if the premiums have been paid for at least" three full years for ordinary insurance or five full years for industrial insurance. Subsection (c)(2) is the default: the policy must "provide that a specified paid-up nonforfeiture benefit is effective as specified by the policy unless the person entitled to make the election elects another available option not later than the 60th day after the due date of a premium payment in default."
Read together, those three subsections fix three things and leave one open. They fix the 60-day window, the three-year threshold for cash, and the rule that a default option takes effect without any action. They leave open which option is the default and which alternatives exist. The phrase "a plan stipulated in the policy" hands the choice of plan to the contract. The phrase "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" describes what an insurer may offer in place of the stipulated benefit, and a longer period of death benefits is the shape of extended term insurance, but the section never uses the words "extended term" or "reduced paid-up" for an option the owner can pick. In the whole chapter, the word "reduced" appears only in section 1105.054, which concerns reduced graded amounts on substandard policies, and the word "Extended" appears only in the names of mortality tables.
Those table names are where extended term appears in Texas chapter 1105. Section 1105.055(f) says that in computing "the present value of any paid-up term insurance with accompanying pure endowment, if any, offered as a nonforfeiture benefit, the rates of mortality assumed may be not more than the rates shown in" the Commissioners 1980 Extended Term Insurance Table for ordinary insurance (the Commissioners 1961 Industrial Extended Term Insurance Table applies to industrial insurance, and subsections (h) to (m) allow later tables adopted by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners to be substituted). So the statute assumes insurers may offer paid-up term insurance with a pure endowment as a nonforfeiture benefit and caps the mortality they may assume in pricing it. It stops short of requiring the benefit to be offered. A pure endowment is a payment to the insured if the insured is still living when the term ends, which is one way a contract can use cash value left over after the term is paid for.
The rest of the section governs the paperwork. Subsection (d)(1)(B) requires a policy that does not change benefits or premiums on a guaranteed basis (policies that do get a statement of method under (d)(1)(A)) to state "the mortality table and interest rate used to compute the cash surrender values and the paid-up nonforfeiture benefits available under the policy, with a table showing the cash surrender value, if any, and paid-up nonforfeiture benefit, if any, available under the policy on each policy anniversary during the first 20 policy years or the term of the policy, whichever is shorter." Subsection (e) adds that the table's values must be computed on the assumption that "there are no dividends or paid-up additions credited to the policy" and "there is no indebtedness to the company on the policy", so a loan is not in the printed numbers. Subsection (d)(3) requires an explanation of how paid-up additions and any indebtedness alter those values. Subsection (g) provides that "A company shall reserve the right to defer payment of any cash surrender value for a period of six months after demand for payment of the cash surrender value and surrender of the policy." Chapter 1105 also does not apply to every policy. Section 1105.003(a) exempts, among others, group insurance, annuities, a term policy of uniform amount that has a term of 20 years or less and expires before the insured reaches 71, and a policy delivered outside Texas through the issuing company's agent.
Five more states with the same skeleton
Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, Washington and South Carolina were checked on their legislatures' own sites on November 3, 2026. Each has a nonforfeiture section built on the same skeleton as Texas: a paid-up benefit on request within 60 days, an alternative that provides a "greater amount or longer period of death benefits", a cash value after three full years of premiums for ordinary insurance, and a stated default unless another option is elected within 60 days. Texas, Washington, Michigan and Illinois also carry the short title "standard nonforfeiture law for life insurance", which fits a uniform law adopted state by state, though the adoption can differ in the details and other states' sections are not in this comparison.
| State and section | Paid-up benefit request window | Alternative benefit wording | Default and election | Cash value after default | Where "extended term" appears |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Texas: Insurance Code 1105.004(b), (c) | "not later than the 60th day after the due date" | "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" | Specified benefit "is effective as specified by the policy" unless another option is elected by the 60th day | On surrender by the 60th day, if premiums paid at least three full years (ordinary) | Only in the names of mortality tables (sections 1105.055, 1105.152, 1105.153) |
| Illinois: 215 ILCS 5/229.2(1)(i) to (iv) | "not later than 60 days after the due date" | "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" | Specified benefit "shall become effective as specified in the policy" unless another is elected within 60 days | Surrender within 60 days, after "at least 3 full years" (ordinary) | Only in the names of mortality tables |
| Michigan: MCL 500.4060(2)(a) to (d) | "not later than 60 days after the due date" | "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" | Specified benefit "will become effective as specified in the policy" unless another is elected within 60 days | Surrender within 60 days, after "not less than 3 full years" (ordinary) | Only in the names of mortality tables; section 4061 separately covers universal life |
| Minnesota: 61A.24, subdivision 2(1) to (4) | "not later than 60 days after the date of the premium in default" in the first clause; "after the due date" in the alternative clause | "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" | Specified benefit "shall become effective as specified in the policy" unless another is elected within 60 days | Surrender within 60 days, after "at least three full years" (ordinary) | Only in the names of mortality tables |
| Washington: RCW 48.76.020(1) to (4) | "not later than sixty days after the due date" | "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" | Specified benefit "becomes effective as specified in the policy" unless another is elected within sixty days | Surrender within sixty days, after "at least three full years" (ordinary) | Only in the names of mortality tables |
| South Carolina: 38-63-520(1) to (4) | "not later than sixty days after the due date" | "greater amount or longer period of death benefits" | Specified benefit "becomes effective as specified in the policy" unless another is elected within sixty days | Surrender within sixty days, after "at least three full years" (ordinary) | In mortality-table names, and in 38-63-220(j) as "the extended term insurance, if any" |
The six statutes agree on the 60-day clock and the three-year cash threshold. All six describe the alternative benefit with the words "greater amount or longer period of death benefits", and none of the six sections in the table names reduced paid-up insurance. South Carolina is the one place in the set where extended term insurance appears as a benefit rather than a table name, and it does so in the reinstatement clause of section 38-63-220(j): a policy may be reinstated within three years after default "unless the policy has been surrendered for its cash value or unless the extended term insurance, if any, has expired." The "if any" is the statute's own admission that the policy may not have one. Minnesota's first clause counts the 60 days from "the date of the premium in default" where its alternative clause counts from "the due date"; the policy's own wording settles which date a particular insurer uses, and a request made well before day 60 avoids the question.
Because the statutes set minimum values and a floor for the owner's rights, a policy can promise more. Texas section 1105.004(a) lets a company use corresponding provisions that the department finds "at least as favorable to the defaulting or surrendering policyholder", and the other five say the same in their own words. A contract that lists extended term, reduced paid-up and cash side by side, with a default of the insurer's choosing, fits inside that frame as long as the values meet the statutory minimum.
Where the worked numbers come from
The mortality input is the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics report United States Life Tables, 2024 (National Vital Statistics Reports, volume 75, number 5, released August 25, 2026, checked November 3, 2026). Table 1 gives the life table for the total population: for each age x, the probability q of dying between x and x + 1. At age 60 that probability is 0.008779, and of 100,000 births, 88,595 are alive at 60 and 70,090 at 75. The final row, "100 and older", carries a probability of 1.000000, so every conversion below treats the last possible death year as the one starting at age 100. The previous edition in the series covers 2023 (NVSR volume 74, number 6, July 15, 2025).
That table describes everyone living in the United States in 2024, not people who buy life insurance, and it is not one of the Commissioners tables that the Texas statute names in sections 1105.005 and 1105.055. It stands in for "a realistic set of death probabilities" so the shape of the answer can be seen with public data, and it should not be read as a stand-in for any insurer's guaranteed basis. A contract's own table of values, printed under subsection (d)(1)(B), uses the mortality table and interest rate the contract names. Minimum values are also formula results, not these results: Texas section 1105.052 builds adjusted premiums with an expense allowance, and the contract may guarantee more.
The interest rate is a labelled illustration: 4 percent a year, applied to death benefits paid at the end of the year of death, which section 1105.010(b) allows ("may be computed on the assumption that any death benefit is payable at the end of the policy year of death"). The figure is not any contract's rate. Texas section 1105.056(a) sets the nonforfeiture interest rate for policies issued before the valuation manual's operative date at 125 percent of the statutory valuation rate, rounded to the nearest one-fourth of one percent, with a floor of four percent, and section 1105.005(c) caps the rate at 3-1/2 percent for computations made on the Commissioners 1941 tables. A table below runs the rate from 3 to 5 percent, so the sensitivity to the choice is on the page instead of hidden in it.
Every conversion uses the same invented policy: a $100,000 face amount with a $15,000 net cash value on the premium due date, at attained ages 40, 50, 60, 70 and 80. Holding the cash value fixed across ages isolates the effect of age. A real policy's cash value would differ at each age, so no row is a forecast for a person aged 40 or 80. No premium and no insurer's value appears in any table here.
The $15,000 cash value at five ages
The table applies both conversions to the same invented policy: $100,000 face, $15,000 net cash value, 4 percent illustrative interest, the CDC 2024 total-population probabilities. The "chance of dying in the term" column is the probability from the same table that the insured dies before the extended period ends; it describes the general population and is not a prediction about any person.
| Attained age at default | Reduced paid-up amount | As a share of $100,000 | Extended term period | Age when term coverage ends | Chance of dying within the term (table) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | $65,939 | 65.9% | 41 years 355 days | 81 years 355 days | 44.5% |
| 50 | $47,965 | 48.0% | 26 years 200 days | 76 years 200 days | 28.5% |
| 60 | $35,584 | 35.6% | 15 years 51 days | 75 years 51 days | 21.2% |
| 70 | $27,298 | 27.3% | 7 years 352 days | 77 years 352 days | 18.0% |
| 80 | $21,545 | 21.5% | 3 years 112 days | 83 years 112 days | 16.4% |
The paid-up amount falls from 65.9 percent of the face amount at 40 to 21.5 percent at 80, and the extended period shrinks from 41 years 355 days to 3 years 112 days. The two columns measure different things, so they fall at different speeds, and the ending age of the term coverage does not fall at all: it is lowest at 60, at 75 years 51 days, and higher on both sides, at 81 years 355 days for the 40-year-old and 83 years 112 days for the 80-year-old. The reason is the shape of the yearly cost: at 40 the first decades cost very little, so the money lasts a long time, and at 80 the cost per year is high from the first year. The chance that a person in the table dies inside the extended period falls steadily, from 44.5 percent to 16.4 percent.
The age-60 row can be checked by hand. At 4 percent, one dollar of whole life coverage for a 60-year-old costs 0.42154, so $15,000 divided by 0.42154 gives $35,584 of paid-up coverage. Run the other way, the first year of term coverage on $100,000 costs 0.008779 divided by 1.04, which is 0.008441 per dollar, or $844. Year by year those costs add up until they use the cash value, and the next table shows where.
How the age-60 term period is found
An extended term period is a running total of annual costs. Each year's cost is the chance of surviving to that year, times the chance of dying in it, times the discount factor, times the face amount. These are pure mortality costs from a population table, with no expenses, profit or underwriting, so none of them is a premium for any person or policy. Across this age range the yearly costs climb, because the probability of death rises with age. The table lists the running total at the end of selected years for the age-60 case.
| Years of term coverage | Cumulative cost of $100,000 of coverage | Share of the $15,000 cash value used | Chance the insured dies within these years (table) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $844 | 5.6% | 0.9% |
| 5 | $4,461 | 29.7% | 5.0% |
| 10 | $9,438 | 62.9% | 11.9% |
| 15 | $14,837 | 98.9% | 20.9% |
| 20 | $20,995 | 140.0% | 33.4% |
| 25 | $27,948 | 186.3% | 50.6% |
| 30 | $34,712 | 231.4% | 70.9% |
The $15,000 is used up between year 15 and year 16. After 15 years the running total is $14,837, which leaves $163, and the sixteenth year alone costs about $1,165 (a 75-year-old survivor faces a probability of death of 0.027586 that year, and fewer than four in five of the original group are still alive to face it). The $163 buys 51 days of that year, which is where "15 years and 51 days" comes from; the day count assumes the cost within the sixteenth year accrues evenly, a simplification a contract may handle differently.
The same table shows why the older cash values buy so little time. The costs in the first five years at 60 are modest, but the cumulative total more than doubles between years 10 and 20 and passes $34,000 by year 30. A cash value that would buy 26 years at age 50 buys 15 at 60 for exactly the reason this column grows: each added year is both more likely to be needed and closer in time.
What moves the answer at age 60
The age-60 case is run again with one input changed at a time: the interest rate, the mortality assumed, and the net cash value after a loan. The first row repeats the base case.
| Input changed (everything else as in the base case) | Reduced paid-up amount | Extended term period |
|---|---|---|
| Interest 3% | $29,193 | 14 years 58 days |
| Interest 3.5% | $32,278 | 14 years 230 days |
| Interest 4% (base case) | $35,584 | 15 years 51 days |
| Interest 5% | $42,869 | 16 years 105 days |
| Mortality at 130% of the table | $32,836 | 12 years 85 days |
| Mortality at 70% of the table | $40,271 | 19 years 221 days |
| $5,000 loan, so net cash value is $10,000 | $23,722 | 10 years 198 days |
Moving the interest rate from 3 to 5 percent raises the paid-up amount by $13,676, or 46.8 percent, and lengthens the term period by 2 years 47 days, or 15.0 percent. Interest matters far more to the paid-up amount than to the term period, because a paid-up policy pays most of its benefit late, where discounting bites hardest. Mortality works the other way. Raising mortality to 130 percent of the table cuts the paid-up amount by 7.7 percent and the term period by 19.2 percent, and lowering it to 70 percent raises the paid-up amount by 13.2 percent and the term period by 29.5 percent. The 130 percent figure is not arbitrary: Texas section 1105.005(d) lets a company assume mortality of up to 130 percent of the applicable table when valuing paid-up term insurance with pure endowment, in computations made on the Commissioners 1941 tables.
The loan row is the one owners most often overlook. A $5,000 loan reduces the net cash value by one third, which cuts the paid-up amount by 33.3 percent and the term period by 30.4 percent. The row uses the simplest treatment, subtracting the loan from the cash value and keeping the face amount at $100,000. Texas section 1105.007(a) subtracts "the amount of any indebtedness to the company on the policy" in computing the minimum cash surrender value after default, but how a contract treats the loan in the face amount of an extended term benefit, or whether it reduces the paid-up amount further, is printed in the contract. The policy loan and lapse guide works through the tax side of an outstanding loan when a policy ends.
What each beneficiary receives, and when
For the age-60 case, the choice changes who is paid and how much depending on when the insured dies.
| Insured dies at age | Extended term pays | Reduced paid-up pays |
|---|---|---|
| 65 | $100,000 | $35,584 |
| 70 | $100,000 | $35,584 |
| 74 | $100,000 | $35,584 |
| 76 | $0 | $35,584 |
| 80 | $0 | $35,584 |
| 90 | $0 | $35,584 |
Extended term pays $64,416 more than reduced paid-up for every death before age 75 years 51 days, and nothing for every death after. Reduced paid-up pays $35,584 whenever the insured dies, as long as the policy is not surrendered. In the CDC table, 79.1 percent of 60-year-olds are alive at 75, so the extended term benefit pays in roughly one case in five, while the paid-up benefit pays in every case. The expected values are equal by construction: the $15,000 cash value buys either one. What differs is the spread. Extended term pays a large amount on a death inside a window and nothing after it. Reduced paid-up pays a smaller amount that arrives whenever death comes.
That framing explains which obligations fit which shape, without recommending either. A debt that ends on a known date, or a dependent's remaining years of need, lines up with a term period, where the full amount is available if the need is still alive and the coverage ends about when the need does. A cost that does not expire, such as final expenses or an amount meant to pass to a beneficiary regardless of the date of death, lines up with coverage for life, which is the paid-up shape. When the need is a mix, neither fits perfectly, and a third route may fit better: the replacement guide covers what is lost by moving to a new policy, and the guide to selling a policy covers the sale route. The retirement guide starts from the survivor-income test that decides whether a need continues at all.
The 60 days after a missed premium
The request windows in the table run from the due date of the premium in default, not from the end of the grace period or the date a notice arrives. On an invented premium due March 1, the 60th day after the due date is April 30. South Carolina's section 38-63-220(i) requires a grace period of "not less than thirty-one days" for any premium after the first, and during it "the policy continues in full force". On that minimum, a grace period would end about April 1 and use the first 31 days of the 60. A decision to take a nonforfeiture benefit therefore belongs to the weeks after the grace period ends, with about four weeks of the 60 days still left. The grace period and reinstatement guide sets out the clocks that run before a policy lapses.
The statutory text makes the election date matter in a second way. Each of the six statutes makes the paid-up nonforfeiture benefit effective as of the due date of the premium in default ("effective as of that due date" in Texas and Michigan, "effective as of such due date" in Illinois, Washington and South Carolina, "effective as of the due date" in Minnesota). The benefit is therefore measured from the default date, not from the day the owner decides. If extended term is the alternative benefit a contract provides, the same wording points to a period that starts on March 1 in the example, so a decision on April 28 would not move the end date; the contract states how it counts. The owner who does nothing receives whichever benefit the policy names as its default, because in each statute the specified benefit takes effect as the policy specifies unless another option is elected inside the window.
Before the clock starts, the policy's own page can settle most of the open points. A useful list to check against the contract:
- Which option is the default. The contract names it, and the statutes do not choose it for the owner.
- Which options exist. Cash, reduced paid-up and extended term are the usual three, and some contracts offer fewer. Where extended term is absent, the choice is between the paid-up benefit and cash.
- The table of values. Texas subsection (d)(1)(B) calls for a table of cash surrender values and paid-up benefits on each anniversary of the first 20 policy years, and the extended term period often appears next to it.
- The mortality table and interest rate. These are the contract's own, and they set every number that the worked examples here only imitate.
- The effect of loans and paid-up additions. Subsection (d)(3) requires an explanation of how indebtedness and paid-up additions alter the values.
- The election form and deadline. Requests are "proper" only if they follow the policy's procedure, so ask the insurer for the form in writing rather than relying on a phone call.
- Reinstatement. South Carolina's clause ties reinstatement to the extended term insurance not having expired, and other states and contracts set their own rules.
Edge cases that change the arithmetic
Policies that do not follow the pattern. Texas section 1105.003(a) lists the exemptions, and a short level term policy is among them: a term policy of uniform amount with a term of 20 years or less that expires before the insured reaches 71 and has uniform premiums payable throughout is outside the chapter. A term policy with no cash value has nothing to convert, so a missed premium ends it unless the contract says otherwise; the term ending options guide covers that case. Michigan's section 4060(1) applies "except as otherwise provided in section 4061 for universal life insurance contracts", which is a reminder that universal life follows its own rules, and the universal life cost of insurance guide explains why its lapse mechanics differ.
Riders. Section 1105.011(a) says that additional benefits such as those payable "in the event of death or dismemberment by accident" or "in the event of total and permanent disability", and the premiums for them, "may not be included in computing a cash surrender value or nonforfeiture benefits required by this chapter". The same section adds that those additional benefits "are not required to be included in any paid-up nonforfeiture benefits". An owner who relies on an accidental death or disability benefit should therefore check whether the contract carries it into the paid-up or term benefit, because the statute does not require it to.
Paid-up additions and dividends. Section 1105.007(a) counts "any existing paid-up additions" among the benefits when valuing the cash surrender value, and subsection (d)(3) of section 1105.004 requires the policy to explain how additions alter the values. An older participating policy can have both a base amount and dividend-purchased additions, so a reduced paid-up figure on the policy's page can mix the two. The invented policy here has none.
Substandard policies. Section 1105.005(e) lets a company, with department approval, specify another mortality table for insurance issued on a substandard basis, and section 1105.055(g) allows modifications to the extended term table. A rated policy can therefore produce different numbers from a standard policy with the same cash value.
Mortality tables in the contract. In the sensitivity table, mortality at 130 percent of the table shortens the age-60 term period by 19.2 percent, against a 15.0 percent difference between the 3 and 5 percent interest rows. Two policies with the same cash value, age and face amount can therefore show different periods if one contract names a table with higher assumed mortality.
Waiting too long. Past the 60-day window, the options narrow, and the contract's default has taken effect. If a cash value existed and the owner took no action, the paid-up or term benefit may already be running. The owner's questions then become reinstatement and replacement rather than election. Checking the contract's table of values now, while premiums are current, costs nothing, and the whole life explainer shows how to read that table next to the illustration. The other permanent policy designs are collected on the policy types hub. Owners who want the loan arithmetic before choosing should read the loan and lapse tax guide first, because an unpaid loan changes every number in the tables above.
Education only, not financial, insurance, tax or legal advice. Every figure above is arithmetic on invented inputs and public data, and none of it predicts what a particular contract will pay. A licensed life insurance agent in your state, or the insurance department, can confirm what the policy provides.
Sources
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, National Vital Statistics Reports, volume 75, number 5: United States Life Tables, 2024 (August 25, 2026), Table 1, life table for the total population, checked November 3, 2026.
- Texas Legislature, Insurance Code chapter 1105, Standard Nonforfeiture Law for Life Insurance (sections 1105.001 to 1105.153), checked November 3, 2026.
- Illinois General Assembly, 215 ILCS 5/229.2, Standard Non-forfeiture Law for Life Insurance, checked November 3, 2026.
- Michigan Legislature, MCL 500.4060 (Michigan Compiled Laws complete through PA 114 of 2026), checked November 3, 2026.
- Minnesota Revisor of Statutes, Minnesota Statutes 61A.24, checked November 3, 2026.
- Washington State Legislature, RCW chapter 48.76 (sections 48.76.010 and 48.76.020), checked November 3, 2026.
- South Carolina Legislature, Code of Laws Title 38, Chapter 63 (sections 38-63-220 and 38-63-520), checked November 3, 2026.
- New York Department of Financial Services, Life insurance consumer guide and glossary (entries "Non-Forfeiture" and "Reduced Paid-up Insurance"), checked November 3, 2026.
Nonforfeiture sections of states other than the six in the comparison are not covered here.
Questions people ask about stopping whole life premiums
Is extended term or reduced paid-up insurance better?
Neither is better on expected value: on the guide's invented policy at age 60, the same $15,000 cash value buys $35,584 of paid-up coverage or $100,000 of term coverage for 15 years and 51 days, and the two are equal in value at the moment of conversion. What differs is the shape. Extended term pays the full amount only if death comes before the term ends, while reduced paid-up pays a smaller amount whenever death comes. A need with an end date fits the first shape and a need with no end date fits the second.
What happens if I stop paying and do nothing?
In the six statutes compared here, the benefit the policy specifies takes effect unless the owner elects another available option within 60 days of the due date. Texas Insurance Code 1105.004(c)(2) says the policy must provide that "a specified paid-up nonforfeiture benefit is effective as specified by the policy" unless the person entitled to elect another option does so by the 60th day. None of the six statutes says which option the policy must name as its default, so the contract is the place to find out.
How long do I have to choose an option after a missed premium?
The six statutes compared here set the window at 60 days from the due date of the premium in default (the 60th day in Texas, "60 days" in Illinois, Michigan and Minnesota, "sixty days" in Washington and South Carolina). The window is counted from the due date, not from the end of the grace period, so a premium due March 1 gives until April 30. A particular contract may allow more time, and the policy's election form states its own deadline.
Can I take the cash value instead of a paid-up benefit?
The statutes in the comparison require a cash surrender value on surrender within 60 days of the due date once premiums have been paid for at least three full years on ordinary insurance (five years on industrial insurance). Texas section 1105.004(g) has the company reserve the right to defer paying a cash surrender value for six months after demand. Before three full years of premiums, these sections do not require a cash surrender value, although Texas section 1105.009(2) still measures a paid-up benefit against the cash value that would have been required without the three-year condition.
Does extended term insurance pay the full face amount?
On the guide's simplest treatment it does, for the length of the period the cash value buys. A loan, paid-up additions or a contract's own method can change that. Texas section 1105.007(a) subtracts "the amount of any indebtedness to the company on the policy" from the present value used for the cash surrender value, and section 1105.004(d)(3) requires the policy to explain how indebtedness and paid-up additions alter the values. The contract's table states the actual amount and the period.
Do these numbers match my policy?
No. The $100,000 face amount, the $15,000 cash value and the 4 percent interest rate are invented, and the mortality table is the CDC's 2024 table for the whole United States population, not a table any insurer uses to compute its guaranteed values. The contract's own table of values, which Texas section 1105.004(d)(1)(B) requires for the first 20 policy years or the policy term, whichever is shorter, controls. The guide's tables show how age, interest, mortality and loans move the result, not what a policy pays.
Can the policy be reinstated after the extended term period starts?
South Carolina's section 38-63-220(j) is the clearest example in the comparison. It requires a provision that the policy may be reinstated within three years after the date of default "unless the policy has been surrendered for its cash value or unless the extended term insurance, if any, has expired", on evidence of insurability and payment of overdue premiums and debt. Other states and contracts set their own reinstatement rules, so the policy and the state's insurance department are the places to confirm.