Permanent policies
Universal Life Cost of Insurance Increase: Reading the Letter
Policy types compared · Updated October 23, 2026
A universal life policy has two sets of cost of insurance rates: the current rates the insurer charges now, which the insurer can change, and the guaranteed maximum rates written into the contract, which it cannot exceed. A notice that the cost of insurance is going up usually means the current rates are moving toward that ceiling. Nothing in the letter forces you to pay more, but the policy's account will drain faster than before, and the lapse date you were counting on has probably moved closer. The letter is a price notice on a contract whose price was never fixed.
Every number in the worked sections is invented to make the arithmetic visible, and the sources are regulators and the NAIC, not carriers. Whether your increase is lawful turns on your contract and your state's law, which an educational page cannot settle for you.
Sources and dates: how we check each figure.
What the contract fixed, and what it left open
Universal life separates three moving parts that other policies bundle together: the premium you choose to pay, the interest the insurer credits to the policy's account, and the charges it takes out, of which the biggest is usually the cost of insurance. The Maryland Insurance Administration's consumer advisory on universal life (the file is dated October 2024) describes the mechanics: the premium is flexible, part of it pays for the insurance and the rest goes into the cash value, and the premium payments plus the cash value must be enough to pay the cost of insurance and administrative charges. In the early years the premium usually exceeds the cost of insurance and builds cash value. The cost of insurance increases each year as the insured ages. If the planned premium is not enough, the shortfall is deducted from the cash value, and when the cash value cannot cover the charges the policy lapses unless the owner raises the premium or lowers the death benefit.
The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, in a consumer alert dated December 3, 2021 (checked October 23, 2026), adds the point that matters here. It says the cost of insurance is the main expense of a universal life policy, that the rate rises as you age, and that in many cases the issuing insurer can increase the rate for the charge because of certain events such as an increase in expenses, but can never increase rates above the guaranteed maximum rates provided in the policy. So two numbers live in your contract: today's rates, and a ceiling. Within the ceiling, a policy's terms and state law govern when and how the insurer may move the current rates. Our indexed universal life guide explains the other piece of the same machinery, how crediting works.
The NAIC Life Insurance Buyer's Guide (2026 edition) states the underlying risk in two sentences: premiums for many policies are sensitive to changes in the company's investment earnings, claims costs and other expenses, and if those are worse than expected, you may have to pay a much higher premium. It tells buyers to ask what the highest premium they would have to pay to keep the coverage might be. A cost of insurance notice is that question arriving in your mailbox.
Why a modest rate change can move a lapse date by years
People respond to these letters by comparing the increase with the monthly bill, find it small, and set it aside. The Wisconsin alert explains why that undercounts the effect. It describes many consumers who set their policies up for level payments based on assumptions at the time of sale, including cost of insurance rates and interest rates. If charges rise or interest falls, the cash value may not be enough to cover the costs of the contract over time, and additional premium may be needed later. Its example: a policyholder bought in 1985 and paid a level premium meant to last to age 100; in 2019 the insurer raised the rate above what was assumed, and the premium being paid was then only enough to fund the policy to age 80. The commissioner's warning is that the owner could reach 80 before realizing the policy is underfunded, when a large premium increase would be needed.
The reason is compounding, as the table in the worked example below shows. The charge is applied to the net amount at risk, the death benefit minus the account value, every year, and the account is what is left after each year's charge. A higher charge in year one leaves a smaller account for year two, which raises the net amount at risk and therefore the year-two charge, and so on. A letter that raises rates once starts a slope, not a step.
Five things to find in the letter and the latest statement
Before deciding anything, pull the notice and your most recent annual statement and find these five items. If any of them is missing from the letter, the missing item is your first question to the insurer.
- What changed. Is it the cost of insurance rate, an administrative charge, the crediting rate, or all three? A notice that mixes these needs each separated.
- The new rate against the guaranteed maximum. The contract lists the maximum by age. The distance between the new current rate and that ceiling tells you how much further the insurer could go without changing the contract.
- Who is affected. Is this one policy, a policy form, or a block of policies? Letters sometimes describe the reason for the change in terms of how a group of policies has performed. Note the stated reason, with the exact wording.
- The effective date. The date the new rate starts, and whether it applies to the next monthly deduction or the next policy anniversary.
- Your account value and net cash surrender value now. The statement shows the policy value at the end of the period and the amounts credited and debited by type, such as interest, mortality and expenses. Those are the inputs of every projection that follows.
One policy year, line by line
An annual statement is the same arithmetic written as a ledger, and reading one is easier once you have done it once by hand. Using the invented policy from the worked example below (death benefit $250,000, account value $62,000 at the start of the year, $6,000 premium, $240 administrative charge, 3.5 percent crediting, and a rate of $38 per $1,000 before the notice and $47.50 after), the year looks like this.
| Ledger line | Year before the notice | Same year after the notice |
|---|---|---|
| Account value, start of year | $62,000 | $62,000 |
| Premium paid | + $6,000 | + $6,000 |
| Administrative charge | - $240 | - $240 |
| Cost of insurance (net amount at risk $188,000 times the rate per $1,000) | - $7,144 | - $8,930 |
| Balance before crediting | $60,616 | $58,830 |
| Interest credited at 3.5 percent | + $2,122 | + $2,059 |
| Account value, end of year | $62,738 | $60,889 |
The ledger shows two effects, not one. The charge rose by $1,786 directly. The account also ended $1,849 lower, because the smaller balance earned $63 less interest. In the "before" column the account grows by $738 in the year; in the "after" column it shrinks by $1,111. That sign change, from growing to shrinking, is what the lapse date is really a function of. In this model the account starts to fall from year 3 even without a notice, so a falling account on your own statement does not by itself show that an increase was applied; compare the charge lines with last year's. The statement's lapse warning line, which Model 582 expects on a flexible-premium policy, is worded on the guaranteed basis, so it can appear while the account is still growing on current rates. Treat it as a prompt to request the in-force illustration, not as proof that a lapse is near.
When you read your real statement, check two more lines the model regulation lists: any loans, because a loan balance reduces the net cash surrender value that keeps the policy alive, and the death benefit at the end of the period, because a change in the death benefit option changes the net amount at risk and the charge with it. If a rider, such as a waiver or term rider, has its own charge, it appears as a separate debit; it is worth confirming which line your notice refers to.
The vocabulary in the letter, and where each term comes from
Notices of this kind use a handful of terms, sometimes loosely. Pinning each to a source keeps an argument with the insurer from turning on what a word means.
| Term in the letter | Plain meaning | Source for the meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of insurance | The charge for the death benefit, the main expense of a universal life policy; it rises with age | Wisconsin OCI consumer alert, Dec 3, 2021 |
| Current rate | The rate in force now, which the insurer may change within contract limits | Wisconsin OCI alert |
| Guaranteed maximum rate | The ceiling stated in the policy; rates can never exceed it | Wisconsin OCI alert |
| Planned premium | The amount you chose to pay; the actual cost may be more or less | Maryland Insurance Administration advisory, Oct 2024 |
| Net cash surrender value | The cash surrender value the annual report lists, and tests against the policy's charges to warn of a lapse | NAIC Model 582, annual report section |
| In-force illustration | An update, available after the first policy anniversary, projecting the policy from today's values | NAIC illustrations page, updated Jan 8, 2026 |
| Non-guaranteed element | A charge or credit the insurer may change, as opposed to one set at issue | NAIC illustrations page |
When the letter uses a term that is not on this list, such as a "re-pricing," a "rate action" or a "policy form adjustment," ask the insurer to say in one sentence which of the above is changing and by how much.
What to ask the insurer, in writing
A written question gets a written answer, and a written answer is what you will want if the matter goes further. Six are enough for most letters.
- Which charge is changing, from what amount to what amount, and from which date?
- What is the guaranteed maximum rate at my attained age and at each later age?
- What reason does the insurer give for the change, and does the policy permit it on that basis?
- Please send an in-force illustration on the current scale and on the guaranteed scale, with the premium needed to keep the policy in force to age 95 on each.
- Does the change apply to all policies on my form, or only some?
- If I reduce the death benefit to a stated amount, what are the new charges and the new lapse date?
The answer to question 3 is where an ordinary owner stops and a licensed attorney or the insurance department may start; you only need to have the answer in hand.
Ask for the in-force illustration
The single most useful document is an in-force illustration, which projects the policy forward from today's values on the insurer's present charges. You are entitled to ask for one. The NAIC Life Insurance Illustrations Model Regulation (Model 582, 2001 text, checked October 23, 2026), in its annual report section, says that if the annual report does not include an in-force illustration it must carry a prominent notice that you should consider requesting more detailed information about the policy, that you should not consider replacement or make changes in your coverage without requesting a current illustration, and that you may request one annually without charge. It adds that if you do not receive a current illustration within 30 days of your request, you should contact your state insurance department. No signature or other acknowledgment of receipt may be required. The same section calls for the annual report on a universal life policy to list the policy value at the start and end of the period, the amounts credited or debited by type, the death benefit, the net cash surrender value and any loans, and to carry a warning if, assuming guaranteed interest, mortality and expense loads, the net cash surrender value will not keep the insurance in force until the end of the next reporting period unless more premium is paid. It also says that if the insurer has made an adverse change in non-guaranteed elements since the last annual report, the report shall contain a notice of that change and its nature. A cost of insurance increase is such a change. States adopt the model on their own terms, so the exact rights depend on where you live; the NAIC's illustrations page (last updated January 8, 2026) explains that in-force illustrations are updates that policy owners may request after the first policy anniversary.
The Wisconsin alert makes the practical request: ask your insurer or agent every year what premium level, on current conditions, would let the coverage last to the date you want. Put that request in writing, name the target age, and ask for three versions: the current scale, the guaranteed scale, and a version that assumes the charges rise again. Then compare. The guaranteed scale is the worst the contract allows, so a premium that keeps the policy alive on the guaranteed scale is the only one that does not depend on the insurer's future choices.
A worked example: one 25 percent increase, four responses
Every number in this section is invented to show the method. They are not rates, quotes or market data. Suppose a level-death-benefit universal life policy for $250,000 held by a 72-year-old, with an account value of $62,000. The net amount at risk is $188,000. Suppose the current rate is $38 per $1,000 a year, so the cost of insurance is 188 times 38, or $7,144 a year. A notice raises the rate 25 percent to $47.50, so the charge becomes $8,930, an increase of $1,786 in the first year. Assume a $240 annual administrative charge, 3.5 percent crediting, a rate that rises 9 percent a year with age, and a $6,000 premium paid at the start of each year.
| Response (invented policy) | Annual premium | Death benefit | Account runs out in policy year | Premium needed to last to age 95 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before the notice | $6,000 | $250,000 | 12 (age 83) | about $11,600 |
| A. Keep paying the same premium after the increase | $6,000 | $250,000 | 9 (age 80) | about $14,200 |
| B. Raise the premium to $10,000 | $10,000 | $250,000 | 14 (age 85) | about $14,200 (same as A) |
| C. Cut the death benefit to $200,000 | $6,000 | $200,000 | 13 (age 84) | about $9,900 |
| D. Cut the death benefit to $150,000 | $6,000 | $150,000 | not within the 40 years modeled | about $5,600 |
Three things stand out. A single 25 percent increase moved the run-out year from 12 to 9, three years earlier, while the first-year bill changed by under $2,000. Raising the premium by two-thirds, to $10,000, bought only five more years in this setup, because the increasing charges keep eating the account. And the death benefit is itself a lever: a smaller benefit means a smaller net amount at risk and a smaller charge. The Maryland advisory lists exactly those two levers, increasing the premium or decreasing the death benefit. Which of them suits a family depends on what the policy is for, and that is the right place to re-ask the question: who is the death benefit meant to protect, and for how long? If the answer is a surviving spouse's housing for a few more years, that is a different amount than a legacy gift. The retirement guide works through that question for older owners.
Responses beyond paying more or shrinking the policy
- Exchange to another contract. Under Internal Revenue Code section 1035(a) (checked October 23, 2026), no gain or loss is recognized on the exchange of a life insurance contract for another life insurance, endowment or annuity contract, or for a qualified long-term care contract. That keeps a tax bill from blocking a move, but the new contract starts from your current age and health, and it may carry its own charges. The Buyer's Guide says to compare a current policy with any new one, notes that health changes can affect your ability to get a new policy or its price, and says not to cancel the current policy until you have the new one. Our replacement guide sets out the questions to ask.
- Convert or ask about internal options. If the policy has riders, loans or features that change the arithmetic, the in-force illustration will show them. A term conversion privilege is a different tool; see conversion options.
- Surrender or stop paying. Under section 72(e)(5), for a life insurance contract that is not a modified endowment contract, amounts received that are not annuity payments are included in income only to the extent they exceed the investment in the contract. A surrender above what you paid in produces taxable gain. Our tax guide works through the numbers, and a tax professional should confirm yours.
- Let a lapse run its course. If the benefit is no longer needed, a planned lapse can be a rational choice, but the grace period and reinstatement rules in our lapse guide apply, and the premium you stop paying may leave nothing behind.
What regulators and consumer groups have said
Increases of this kind are not new. On February 1, 2016, the Consumer Federation of America wrote to state insurance commissioners asking them to study and prohibit unfair increases to the cost of insurance charges on universal life policies, naming three insurers, AXA Equitable, VOYA Financial and Transamerica, that it said had notified agents of increases (CFA press release, checked October 23, 2026). CFA's actuary argued that insurers should justify increases by showing that actual mortality experience exceeds the assumptions used when the policies were sold. That is an advocacy position from 2016, not a rule or a ruling, and the page does not say what any regulator did in response. It is cited only to show that the dispute over how and when current charges may rise has a public history.
The regulators' own language is more cautious. Wisconsin's alert says the increase is permitted within the guaranteed maximum, and recommends yearly monitoring. Neither Wisconsin's alert nor Maryland's advisory tells you that a given increase is allowed or not, because that turns on the contract and the facts.
Who to contact if the letter does not add up
Begin with the insurer, in writing, with a request for the information the five-item list above asks for, and for the basis of the increase as stated in the policy. If the answer is missing, late or unclear, the next office is your state insurance department. The Maryland Insurance Administration's advisory gives its numbers (410-468-2000 or 800-492-6116) and says it can investigate complaints about improperly terminated policies, premiums raised without proper notice or beyond what the law allows, and false statements in connection with processing claims. Other states publish their own complaint routes, and the NAIC's Insurance Departments page (checked October 23, 2026) is the place to find yours.
Some policyholders also look for legal help with these notices. Whether a particular increase is a breach of the contract or a violation of state law is a legal question that depends on the policy language, the stated reasons for the increase, and the law of the state, and it is outside what any general guide can answer. A licensed attorney who handles insurance disputes in your state can evaluate the contract. The limit is time: a policy that is allowed to lapse while the question is being asked may be harder to restore, so keep the policy in force while you gather the facts, if you can afford to.
Setting the trigger for your next decision
The most useful thing to take from a notice like this is a rule you set in advance, while you are calm, about what result from the next in-force illustration would make you act. A workable form is a lapse-age test: choose the age you need the coverage to reach, write it down, and decide now that if the current-scale illustration shows the account running out before that age, you will move to the next step on your list, whether that is a higher premium, a smaller death benefit or a review of replacement. In the worked example, a policyholder with a trigger of age 82 would not have been alerted before the notice, because the run-out was age 83, and would have been alerted by it, because the run-out moved to age 80. A rule like that turns each annual illustration from a document you file into a decision you make.
Keep the letter, the annual statements before and after it, and the dates you asked for and received each illustration, because a sequence of dated documents is what a regulator or an attorney will ask for first. The sources behind this page are educational, not legal: TrueLifeCost does not sell insurance, cannot say whether a particular rate increase is allowed under your contract or state law, and the figures in the worked example are invented to show the method, not rates or quotes.
Questions policyholders ask about a cost of insurance notice
Can my insurer raise the cost of insurance on a universal life policy?
Usually within limits written into the contract. The Wisconsin insurance commissioner's consumer alert says that in many cases the insurer can increase the rate for the cost of insurance charge due to events such as increased expenses, but can never go above the guaranteed maximum rates stated in the policy. Whether a specific increase follows the contract is a question for the policy language and your state insurance department.
What is the difference between current and guaranteed cost of insurance rates?
Current rates are what the insurer charges now and may change. Guaranteed maximum rates are the ceiling in the contract. Projections on the current scale depend on the insurer's choices; projections on the guaranteed scale show the worst case the contract allows.
How do I request an in-force illustration?
Write to the insurer or ask your agent. Under the NAIC illustrations model, an owner may request one annually without charge, no signature may be required, and if you do not receive one within 30 days of asking you should contact your state insurance department. Ask for the current scale and the guaranteed scale, and name the age you want the coverage to last to.
Should I pay more, lower the death benefit, or replace the policy?
It depends on what the coverage is for and what you can afford. Regulators name raising the premium or lowering the death benefit as the ways to keep a policy in force. Replacing it can trigger new underwriting and charges, so compare in writing and do not cancel the old policy until the new one is in force. A licensed agent or a fee-only adviser can help you run the comparison.
Is surrendering a universal life policy taxable?
It can be. For a policy that is not a modified endowment contract, amounts received are included in income only to the extent they exceed the investment in the contract. A surrender for more than you paid in produces a taxable gain, reported on the form the insurer sends. A tax professional should confirm your figures.
Where do I complain about a cost of insurance increase?
Start with the insurer in writing, then your state insurance department. The Maryland Insurance Administration, for example, says it can investigate complaints that premiums were raised without proper notice or beyond what the law allows. The NAIC website links to each state's department.