Skip to main content

Policy types compared

IUL vs 401(k) and Roth IRA: What the Illustration Leaves Out

Policy types compared · Updated October 23, 2026

A 401(k) and a Roth IRA are tax-advantaged investment accounts. An indexed universal life (IUL) policy is a life insurance contract with a cash value account attached. Which one leaves you with more money is a question about arithmetic, and the answer changes with a handful of assumptions. In the model below, with every assumption stated, an IUL's cash value over 30 years earns roughly 5 percent a year on the premiums paid when the account is credited at 6 percent and charges are middling. An alternative that nets more than about 5 percent ends ahead on cash value alone, and one that nets less ends behind. The death benefit, which a 401(k) and a Roth IRA do not have, sits outside that arithmetic.

The numbers below are teaching numbers, not quotes, and every assumption is labelled. The sources are the IRS, the Internal Revenue Code and the NAIC illustration regulation. Our IUL explainer covers how crediting works, and this page starts where that one stops.

Sources and dates: how we check each figure.

Three containers for the same dollars

The structural differences come first, because they decide which comparisons are fair. The federal rules in the table come from IRS pages and the Internal Revenue Code, checked October 23, 2026.

Feature401(k) (pre-tax)Roth IRAIUL policy
What it isEmployer retirement planIndividual retirement accountLife insurance contract with a cash value account
Contribution tax treatmentElective deferrals excluded from taxable income (Roth deferrals are not)Contributions not deductiblePremiums paid from after-tax money; not deductible
Tax on growthDeferredNone if distributions qualifyNot taxed as it builds, if the contract meets the tax definition of life insurance
Tax on taking money outDistributions, including earnings, are taxable income at retirementQualified distributions are tax-freeWithdrawals taxed only above what you paid in; loans are not treated as received for a non-MEC contract
2026 contribution limit$24,500 employee deferral; $8,000 extra if 50 or older$7,500 ($1,100 extra if 50 or older); income phase-outs applyNo set dollar cap, but premiums are limited by the tax tests in sections 7702 and 7702A
Early access10 percent additional tax before 59 and a half unless an exception appliesGoverned by the IRS early-distribution and Roth rules, which this page does not coverSurrender charges and policy terms apply; see the contract
Death benefitNone; the account balance passes to beneficiariesNone; the account balance passes to beneficiariesYes, in a stated amount
Employer matchOften availableNoneNone
GuaranteesNone on investment valueNone on investment valueContract guarantees, which an illustration must show separately from non-guaranteed elements, alongside charges and credits the insurer can change

Sources for the rows: the IRS 2026 limits announcement (IR-2025-111, November 13, 2025) for the dollar limits and the Roth IRA phase-out of $153,000 to $168,000 for single filers and $242,000 to $252,000 for married couples filing jointly; the IRS 401(k) plans page (updated January 30, 2026) for the pre-tax exclusion and the taxation of distributions; the IRS Roth IRA page for non-deductible contributions and tax-free qualified distributions; the IRS early distributions page for the 10 percent additional tax and its list of exceptions; and section 72(e)(5) for the treatment of amounts received under a life insurance contract.

Two cells need care. "Loans are not treated as received for a non-MEC contract" follows from section 72(e)(5)(A), which switches off the loan-as-distribution rule in 72(e)(4)(A) for covered life insurance contracts, subject to the modified endowment rules. A modified endowment contract (MEC) is one entered into on or after June 21, 1988 that fails the 7-pay test in section 7702A, meaning more was paid in during the first seven years than level premiums for a policy paid up after seven years would have required; the tax treatment of a MEC is less favorable, as our tax guide explains. And what happens for tax purposes if a policy with an outstanding loan lapses is not covered by the sources we read, so we do not state it; that is a question for a tax professional before any loan is taken.

Why "room" is true for some savers and irrelevant for others

A common sales point is that an IUL has no contribution limit. That is not quite right, because section 7702 limits how much premium a policy can take while still counting as life insurance: a contract passes either a cash value accumulation test or the combination of a guideline premium limitation and a cash value corridor. The corridor requires the death benefit to be at least a set percentage of the cash surrender value, 250 percent for an insured at or under 40, falling in steps to 105 percent at ages 75 to 90 (section 7702(d)). The practical effect is that premiums are capped by the death benefit you buy, and a high-premium design needs a large death benefit and its charges.

Whether the cap matters depends on how much you save. In 2026, an employee under 50 can defer up to $24,500 into a 401(k) and, if eligible, put $7,500 into a Roth IRA, a total of $32,000 before any employer contribution. A saver putting away $6,000 a year, the amount used in the model below, uses a fraction of that room, so the "no limit" point is irrelevant to them. A saver trying to put away $60,000 a year after filling 401(k) and IRA space is in a different position, and for that saver the question is not IUL versus 401(k) at all, but what to do with money beyond tax-advantaged space; taxable accounts and other vehicles belong in that comparison, and this page does not rank them.

Turning an illustration into a rate of return

The most useful technique on this page needs no software. An illustration prints a ledger: for each year, the premium, the death benefit, and the cash surrender value. The cash surrender value is the money you could walk away with; the "accumulated value" column is larger and is not the same thing. Take the premiums you would pay and the cash surrender value in a year you might plausibly exit, and ask what annual rate of return connects them. That rate is the policy's internal rate of return on the cash value (IRR), the same measure you would use for any investment where you put money in regularly and take a lump sum out.

The NAIC's Life Insurance Illustrations Model Regulation (Model 582, 2001 text, checked October 23, 2026) is the reason the ledger comes in three versions. A basic illustration must show a numeric summary of death benefits and values for at least policy years five, ten and twenty and at age 70 on three bases: the policy's guarantees, the insurer's illustrated scale, and a midpoint scale with non-guaranteed credited interest and charges set at the average of the guaranteed and illustrated rates. It must also carry a statement that the illustration assumes the currently illustrated non-guaranteed elements will continue unchanged for all years shown, that this is not likely to occur, and that actual results may be more or less favorable. Run the IRR on all three columns. The guarantees column shows what the contract promises. The illustrated column shows the sales case. The midpoint column is the regulator's own stress test, and its IRR is the one to treat as the working estimate if you have no other basis.

The NAIC's illustrations page (last updated January 8, 2026) adds the context for indexed products: the NAIC adopted Actuarial Guideline 49 in 2015 to bring uniformity to illustrations of policies tied to an external index, AG 49-A applies to policies sold on or after December 14, 2020, revisions in 2023 tightened illustration limits, and revisions in 2026 enhanced consumer-protection disclosures. We could not fetch the guideline text itself, so we state no numeric limits from it. The practical point is that an illustration is regulated, which is not the same as being a forecast.

The three columns, run through the same model

To see why the regulation insists on three bases, run the model's cash values through the IRR method on three invented scales that stand in for them. The "illustrated" scale is the 6 percent credit and medium charges used below. The "guaranteed" scale uses a 2 percent credit and charges at twice the medium level. The "midpoint" scale sits halfway between the two: a 4 percent credit and charges at 1.5 times medium. These stand-ins are labelled inventions; a real ledger replaces them.

Scale (invented)Cash value, year 5Year 10Year 20Year 30IRR at year 10 / 20 / 30
Guaranteed$25,771$52,683$107,963$159,152-2.38 / -1.02 / -0.81 percent
Midpoint$28,384$61,746$146,691$265,3620.52 / 1.88 / 2.40 percent
Illustrated$31,197$72,160$197,479$421,5233.33 / 4.53 / 5.04 percent

The spread is the lesson. On these inventions the same premiums produce a thirty-year cash value of $159,152, $265,362 or $421,523 depending on which scale turns out closest to the truth, a range wide enough to turn the comparison with any alternative inside out. A sales conversation that shows only the illustrated line is showing one of three. A ledger that shows all three lets you ask the right question: not "what will this earn?" but "what must the insurer's non-guaranteed elements do for this to be worth holding?"

A 30-year model with every assumption on the table

Everything in this section is invented to show the method. These are not quotes, rates or predictions. The assumptions:

  • The saver is 35 and puts $6,000 a year, after tax, into one of the vehicles for 30 years, paid at the start of each year, for a total of $180,000.
  • The Roth IRA or equivalent after-tax account earns a constant net return of 4, 6 or 8 percent a year, after any fund fees. Real returns vary year to year; a constant rate removes volatility so the comparison is clean.
  • The 401(k) contribution is sized so the take-home cost is the same $6,000. At an assumed 22 percent marginal tax rate now, that means contributing $7,692 pre-tax. The withdrawal tax rate is assumed to be either 22 or 12 percent.
  • The IUL has a $400,000 death benefit, a 5 percent premium load, a $120 annual charge, and an invented cost of insurance that starts at $0.80 per $1,000 of net amount at risk and rises 8.5 percent a year ("medium"), with a "low" version at 70 percent of that and a "high" version at 150 percent. The account is credited at 4, 6 or 7 percent a year; the credit stands in for whatever the index, cap and participation rate produce. The model raises the death benefit when the section 7702(d) corridor requires it. It ignores surrender charges, which would lower early-year values, and it ignores any loan interest.

None of the charge levels comes from a carrier or a benchmark. They are placed to span a plausible range, so the headline figure of about 5 percent is a product of those choices and not a typical result. The 7 percent credit stands for a design with a generous cap or a favorable index run, which is itself an assumption.

Vehicle (assumptions as listed)Value after 30 yearsAfter-tax value if taken as taxable income at 22 percent / 12 percent
Roth IRA or after-tax account, 4 percent net$349,970$349,970 (tax-free if qualified)
Roth IRA, 6 percent net$502,810$502,810
Roth IRA, 8 percent net$734,075$734,075
401(k), 4 percent net ($7,692 a year pre-tax)$448,680 before tax$349,970 / $394,838
401(k), 6 percent net$644,628 before tax$502,810 / $567,273
401(k), 8 percent net$941,122 before tax$734,075 / $828,187
IUL, medium charges, credited 4 percent$286,744 cash valueWithdrawals are taxed only above what you paid in; loans are not treated as received for a non-MEC contract; loan interest and lapse risk remain
IUL, medium charges, credited 6 percent$421,523 cash valueSame
IUL, medium charges, credited 7 percent$510,921 cash valueSame

Two features of the table are worth stating plainly. The first is that a pre-tax 401(k) and a Roth end up identical when the tax rate at withdrawal equals the rate you avoided at contribution, here 22 percent in both, and they differ only by the difference between the two rates. That is why the withdrawal rate is an assumption, not a detail. A retiree in a 12 percent bracket does better with the pre-tax account in this setup, and one in a higher bracket does worse. The second is that the IUL figures are cash surrender values on a policy that also carries a death benefit of at least $400,000 for all 30 years, which the other two do not.

Which inputs flip the answer

The table above fixes the IUL's charges at medium. The next one varies both inputs that matter most, the credited rate and the charges, and reports the annual return on the premiums paid if the policy is held for 30 years.

IUL, 30-year IRR on $6,000 a yearCredited 4 percentCredited 6 percentCredited 7 percent
Low charges3.10 percent5.22 percent6.25 percent
Medium charges2.85 percent5.04 percent6.09 percent
High charges2.40 percent4.71 percent5.79 percent

Read it with the Roth results next to it. A Roth earning 4 percent ($349,970) finishes ahead of the IUL credited at 4 percent ($286,744, medium charges) but behind the IUL credited at 6 percent ($421,523), while a Roth earning 6 percent ($502,810) finishes ahead of both. The break-even sits close to the IUL's own IRR, roughly 4.7 to 5.2 percent at a 6 percent credit. If you believe your alternative will net more than that over three decades, it ends ahead on cash value; if you believe it will net less, the policy does. Nothing in the arithmetic says which belief is right, and the credited rate that goes into the IUL is itself uncertain: the index, cap, participation rate and the insurer's ability to change non-guaranteed elements determine whether 6 percent is a reasonable assumption.

The time horizon is a third input, and a big one. In the medium case with a 6 percent credit, the same policy's IRR is 3.33 percent at 10 years, 4.53 percent at 20 years and 5.04 percent at 30 years, using the model's cash values. The early years are weighed down by the premium load and by charges that fall on a mostly empty account, and real contracts add surrender charges that the model leaves out. A saver who might need to exit within ten years should run the 10-year line on the real ledger, not the 30-year one.

What the arithmetic leaves out, in both directions

A comparison of cash values alone treats an insurance policy as an inferior investment account, and that is too narrow. It also ignores things that favor the account. Each side has a fair list.

  • The death benefit has a value that is not in the IRR. In the model, a death in year 10 produces a $400,000 benefit against $60,000 of premiums paid; the Roth IRA, at 6 percent, would hold about $83,800. Whether that benefit is worth having depends on whether anyone needs it; the NAIC Buyer's Guide asks who depends on you financially and what continuing needs would go unpaid. If someone does, the sensible comparison is against the cost of the same protection bought separately, which our site does not price, but which the quote worksheet can total from quotes you receive.
  • The insurer can change charges; the account cannot. Non-guaranteed elements in an IUL are set by the insurer within contract limits. A 401(k) or Roth IRA holds whatever the market returns, with fund fees you can see. Our cost of insurance guide shows how a rate change moves a universal life policy's lapse date.
  • Behavior is part of the return. A policy that lapses after a few years returns less than any column on the ledger, because the early charges are sunk. A retirement account the saver stops funding returns whatever it has earned. Which failure is likelier depends on the saver.
  • Access differs. The IRS lists the 10 percent additional tax on retirement-account distributions before 59 and a half, with exceptions. IUL access is through withdrawals and loans under the contract, with its own costs and limits; ask the insurer for the loan interest rate and the rate credited to the loaned amount.
  • Financial aid treatment is close to a tie. The federal aid handbook excludes both retirement plans and life insurance cash value from FAFSA assets, so neither column helps or hurts the Student Aid Index while the money stays put. The difference comes on the way out: retirement distributions count as income, while policy loans do not, though loan cash held in a bank on signing day is an asset. Our guide to cash value on the FAFSA runs the arithmetic.
  • Tax rates are uncertain on both sides. The pre-tax 401(k) bets on a lower rate in retirement; the Roth and the IUL pay tax now. Future rates are unknown.

The match changes the question

If your employer matches 401(k) contributions, the comparison is lopsided before any assumption about returns, because the match is a return available only through the plan. On invented numbers, suppose the employer adds 50 cents for each dollar you defer, up to $6,000 of deferrals: $3,000 a year. That is a 50 percent return in the first year, before any investment growth. Over 30 years, $3,000 a year at 6 percent grows to about $251,000 before tax. An IUL IRR near 5 percent is not in the same range as a 50 percent instant return on matched dollars, so a saver who is not capturing a match faces a different decision from one who is. The sources we fetched do not describe match formulas, and vesting schedules can limit what you keep, so check your own plan's terms. The match is a reason to learn what your plan offers before any other step, and our employer group life guide covers the life insurance side of workplace benefits.

Testing the claims made on each side

Pages that make this comparison for you tend to repeat a few claims, some in favor of an IUL and some against it. Each has a fair test, and the tests apply equally to both sides. None implies a product is a poor choice; the tests are what a claim has to survive.

The claimThe fair test
"Tax-free retirement income"Ask whether the income is withdrawals or loans, what the loan interest rate and credited rate are, and what happens to taxes if the policy lapses with a loan. We could not source the lapse-with-loan tax result and do not state it.
"No market losses"Where a contract has an index floor, it protects against negative index credits; it does not protect against charges, which are deducted every year. In the model, the 4 percent credit case lost to a plain 4 percent account because of charges.
"Beats a 401(k) in the illustration"Check whether the illustration compares an IUL's cash value with the 401(k)'s pre-tax balance, or both after tax, and whether it uses the illustrated column or the midpoint column.
"No contribution limits"Premium is capped by section 7702 and 7702A; ask the insurer which test the policy uses and whether the planned premium makes it a MEC.
"The cap and participation rates are strong"Ask how long the insurer has held them and whether they can change. Rates are non-guaranteed, and the illustration assumes they stay put.
"An index fund returns 8 percent a year"A constant 8 percent is an assumption. Real returns arrive unevenly, and the order of good and bad years affects what a saver who is also withdrawing money ends up with. The model on this page uses constant rates to keep the comparison clean, which also hides that risk.
"Roth withdrawals are always tax-free"The IRS says qualified distributions are tax-free. Whether a given withdrawal is qualified depends on rules this page does not cover, so check the Roth rules for your account before relying on the label.
"A 401(k) beats life insurance every time"That compares cash values only. It leaves out the death benefit, any need for one, and the tax rate you will face when you withdraw. A pre-tax 401(k) is taxed on the way out, as the table above shows.
"Fees are lower in a 401(k)"Plan fees vary by plan and fund. Look at the expense ratios and plan fees in your own plan documents instead of assuming, and compare them with the premium load and charges on the policy ledger.

Where this leaves a decision

The arithmetic is simple to state: put the same dollars into each vehicle, subtract the charges, and see what the cash value is worth in the year you might need it, and what you would have paid to get the death benefit another way. The choice depends on inputs that are yours, not ours: whether you need a death benefit, what your plan's match is, whether you have used your tax-advantaged room, how long you would hold the policy, and what you believe about returns and tax rates. If part of the decision is whether to replace an existing policy with an IUL, the replacement guide covers what to check before you give up what you have, and our guide to term versus whole life covers the other permanent-coverage comparison.

IUL, 401(k) and Roth IRA: common questions

Is an IUL better than a 401(k)?

Neither is better in general. A 401(k) and a Roth IRA are tax-advantaged investment accounts and often come with an employer match; an IUL is a life insurance contract with a death benefit and charges. In the model on this page, an IUL's 30-year cash value returned roughly 5 percent a year on premiums at a 6 percent credit and medium charges, so an alternative netting more than that ended ahead on cash value alone.

What are the 2026 contribution limits for a 401(k) and a Roth IRA?

According to the IRS announcement of November 13, 2025, the 401(k) employee deferral limit for 2026 is $24,500, with an extra $8,000 for those 50 and older, and the IRA limit is $7,500, with an extra $1,100 for those 50 and older. The Roth IRA income phase-out is $153,000 to $168,000 for single filers and $242,000 to $252,000 for married couples filing jointly.

Are IUL loans tax-free?

For a policy that is not a modified endowment contract, the tax code does not treat a loan as an amount received, and amounts received are taxed only to the extent they exceed what you paid in. That is not the same as risk-free: loans carry interest, and the sources we read do not state the tax result if a policy lapses with a loan outstanding, so ask a tax professional first.

Does an IUL have contribution limits?

Not a fixed dollar cap like a 401(k), but the tax code limits how much premium a policy can take while qualifying as life insurance, through the tests in sections 7702 and 7702A. Going over the 7-pay test makes it a modified endowment contract with less favorable tax treatment.

How do I calculate the return on an IUL illustration?

Take the premiums you would pay each year and the cash surrender value shown in the year you might exit, not the accumulated value, and find the annual rate that connects them. Do it on the guaranteed, illustrated and midpoint columns that the NAIC illustration regulation requires at years five, ten and twenty and at age 70.

Why is the employer match so important in this comparison?

Because it is a return available only through the plan. A match of 50 cents per dollar is a 50 percent return in the first year before any investment growth, which a policy's long-run return does not approach. Check your plan's match and vesting rules before deciding where other savings go.