Disputed claims
Life Insurance Interpleader: When Two People Claim the Same Death Benefit
Claims and beneficiaries · Updated October 31, 2026
An insurer facing two claims to the same life insurance benefit does not have to pick a winner. It files an interpleader: it deposits the money with a court, names both claimants as defendants, asks to be released from any further liability, and leaves the judge to decide who is paid. In federal court the statute that allows this, 28 U.S.C. 1335, needs only $500 or more at stake and two adverse claimants who are citizens of different states. The insurer usually asks to be paid its own attorney fees out of the deposit, and in seven federal orders we read, judges allowed between $400 and $17,037, and in one case nothing at all.
The money does not shrink much from fees alone. In a 2013 Missouri order, a $1,001,072.74 deposit lost $17,037 to the insurer's fees and costs, 1.70 percent of the fund. In a 2017 New Jersey order, a $39,250 group life benefit lost $4,572.40, or 11.65 percent. The larger cost of an interpleader is usually time and the claimants' own lawyers, and both of those are things the claimants can still control in the weeks before the insurer files.
Sources and dates: how we check each figure.
What an interpleader asks a court to do
An insurer facing two claims to one benefit has a real problem. If it pays the named beneficiary and a court later decides a former spouse, a child or an estate was entitled, it can be ordered to pay a second time. Interpleader exists so that a stakeholder holding money it admits it owes can hand the money to a court and let the rivals fight each other instead of the stakeholder. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 22 frames the trigger plainly: persons whose claims "may expose a plaintiff to double or multiple liability" may be joined as defendants "and required to interplead."
A typical federal interpleader moves through four steps:
- The complaint. The insurer files a complaint in interpleader naming every person who has claimed, or might claim, the benefit. It states the amount due and that it takes no side.
- The deposit. Under the statute, the insurer pays the benefit into the court's registry or posts a bond when it files. Under the rule, it asks leave of court to deposit under Rule 67.
- The discharge. Once the money is in the registry, the insurer moves to be dismissed and discharged from further liability, and usually asks for its fees and costs from the fund.
- The claimants' case. The claimants are left as the only parties. They plead their claims to the fund, exchange evidence, and either settle or let the court decide, after which the court orders the clerk to pay out.
Nothing in that sequence decides who is right. An insurer that interpleads is conceding it owes the money; the case is about who it is owed to. A claimant who wants to accuse the insurer of misconduct needs evidence: the Minnesota court in the table below rejected one claimant's suggestion that the insurer owed her fees because she had shown nothing "improvident, vexatious, or otherwise in bad faith" in its conduct.
Two routes into federal court: the statute and Rule 22
Federal interpleader comes in two forms that look alike and behave differently. Statutory interpleader rests on three sections of Title 28: section 1335 grants jurisdiction, section 1397 sets venue, and section 2361 gives the court its process and injunction powers. Rule interpleader rests on Rule 22, which is only a procedure and needs some other basis for a federal court to hear the case. Rule 22(b) says the rule is in addition to the statutes and does not limit them, and that an action under the statutes is conducted under the federal rules.
| Feature | Statutory interpleader (28 U.S.C. 1335, 1397, 2361) | Rule interpleader (FRCP 22) |
|---|---|---|
| Amount needed | $500 or more | More than $75,000 for diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. 1332; no minimum on a federal-question basis |
| Citizenship | Two or more adverse claimants of diverse citizenship (minimal diversity among claimants) | For diversity, citizenship diversity under 28 U.S.C. 1332 between the insurer and the claimants |
| Other route in | None needed | A federal question, for example an employer plan governed by ERISA |
| Deposit | Required at filing: deposit into the registry or a bond set by the court | By leave of court under Rule 67; not a filing condition |
| Venue | Any district where one or more claimants reside | Ordinary federal venue rules; section 1397 does not apply |
| Reaching claimants and stopping other suits | Nationwide process served by U.S. marshals; the court may restrain claimants from suing in any state or federal court | Section 2361 is not available |
| Claims that differ in origin | Allowed by 1335(b) | Allowed by Rule 22(a)(1)(A) |
The difference matters most in the injunction row. In the 2008 Alabama order in our table, the insurer had filed under Rule 22 but asked the judge for a section 2361 order barring the claimants from suing it anywhere else. The court refused, calling it "black-letter law that § 2361 is not available in the rule interpleader context." The insurer was still discharged and dismissed, but without the nationwide injunction.
Group life through an employer often arrives by the federal-question route. The 2017 New Jersey case was a Rule 22 interpleader by an insurer acting as an ERISA fiduciary for an employer plan; the judge found federal-question jurisdiction because the dispute was over ERISA plan benefits, even though the $39,250 benefit was below the $75,000 diversity threshold. The same opinion summed up the split: section 1335 confers jurisdiction on "minimal diversity" and $500, while Rule 22 "is merely a procedural device" that assumes jurisdiction already exists.
A claimant can also be on the other side of the caption. Rule 22(a)(2) lets a defendant seek interpleader by counterclaim or crossclaim. In the 2013 Arkansas case, a beneficiary sued the insurer in state court, the insurer removed the case to federal court and filed a counterclaim and third-party complaint in interpleader, and the $500,000 benefit went into the registry. States have their own interpleader procedures as well, and an insurer can file in state court instead; the fee and timing figures below come only from federal orders.
Where a deposited benefit sits
The deposit is not handed to a judge in a check. Under 28 U.S.C. 2041, money paid into a federal court goes to the U.S. Treasury or a designated depositary in the court's name. Rule 67(b) requires that it be placed "in an interest-bearing account" or a court-approved interest-bearing instrument. In practice the federal courts invest registry money through the Court Registry Investment System, and for interpleaders filed under section 1335 the Judicial Conference fee schedule refers to a separate Disputed Ownership Fund inside that system.
Three rules then govern the money while it waits:
- It leaves only by court order. Section 2042 says no deposited money "shall be withdrawn except by order of court." A signed settlement between claimants still needs a disbursement order before the clerk pays.
- The court charges a fee out of the interest. The District Court Miscellaneous Fee Schedule, effective December 1, 2023, sets an annual fee of 20 basis points (0.20 percent) of assets on deposit for section 1335 funds held in the Disputed Ownership Fund, and 10 basis points for other registry funds invested in the system. Both come out of interest earnings, and the Director of the Administrative Office may waive them for cause.
- Unclaimed money goes to the Treasury after five years. If the right to withdraw has been decided or is undisputed and the money sits unclaimed for at least five years, section 2042 sends it to the Treasury in the name of the United States. The person entitled can still petition the court for it, on notice to the U.S. attorney and with full proof.
The fund also has its own tax position. Treasury Regulation 1.468B-9 defines a "disputed ownership fund" as one set up to hold property subject to conflicting ownership claims, under a court's continuing jurisdiction, that pays out only with court approval. Its Example 3 is a life insurance interpleader: a current and a former spouse claim a $1 million benefit, the insurer deposits it, and the fund earns $12,000 of interest before a court decides. The regulation says the $1 million deposit is not the fund's income but the $12,000 of interest is. A fund holding only passive investment assets is taxed as a qualified settlement fund, and Regulation 1.468B-2(a) taxes that kind of fund at the maximum rate under section 1(e) of the Internal Revenue Code, which 26 U.S.C. 1(j) currently sets at 37 percent for trusts and estates (the statutory table starts that bracket at $12,500 of income, a figure adjusted for inflation each year). Whether the winning claimant owes tax on what is distributed is decided under the general rules; our guide on whether life insurance is taxable covers the death benefit side.
Fee awards in seven federal orders, 2008 to 2020
Every row below comes from the text of a federal district court order published in the govinfo United States Courts Opinions collection. The amounts are what each order allowed the insurer to take, set against what it asked for. The percentage column uses the fund or benefit amount the order itself states as its base.
| Court and order date | Fund or benefit stated in the order | Insurer asked for | Court allowed | Allowed as a share of the stated fund | What drove the number |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S.D. Alabama, Nov 13, 2008 (No. 1:08-cv-00211) | $102,913.72 deposited (benefit plus accrued interest) | $5,930.01 fees and costs | $0 | 0% | Denied under the Eleventh Circuit rule that fees are not warranted when the dispute arises in the normal course of the insurer's business |
| E.D. Missouri, Jan 29, 2013 (No. 4:12-cv-01253) | $1,001,072.74 deposited (death benefit plus a $1,072.74 premium refund) | $22,982.50 fees plus $1,641.31 costs ($24,623.81) | $16,487 fees plus $550 costs ($17,037) | 1.70% of the deposit | Hourly rates cut to local levels (a $525 partner rate to $350); 5 hours removed from 19 spent on the complaint and deposit motions |
| D. Minnesota, Mar 27, 2013 (No. 0:12-cv-00582) | $105,000 policy | $10,665 | $6,564.55 | 6.25% of the policy amount | $1,730 removed for redacted billing entries, $1,212 removed for time spent on the fee motion, then a 15 percent cut |
| E.D. Arkansas, May 10, 2013 (No. 3:12-cv-00105) | $500,000 deposited | $24,333.00 fees plus $172.49 costs | $10,125.00 fees plus $69.30 costs ($10,194.30) | 2.04% of the deposit | 81.0 claimed hours on core work reduced to 40.5 at a $250 blended rate; fee motion, garnishment and stay-motion time disallowed; legal research and phone charges refused as costs |
| S.D. Ohio, Jan 11, 2017 (No. 2:15-cv-02693) | $651,350.64 deposited ($609,752.00 of proceeds plus interest from proof of claim) | $11,419.45 through Oct 3, 2016 | $11,419.45, plus later fees through the deposit date | 1.75% of the deposit (before the later fees) | Unopposed; the only response asked that any award come from the fund |
| D. New Jersey, Sep 8, 2017 (No. 2:16-cv-07486) | $39,250 employer plan benefit | $4,572.40 | $4,572.40 deducted from the benefit | 11.65% of the benefit | About 6 partner hours at $207 and 15 associate hours at $201, all for the interpleader itself; the claimants had been warned and given time to settle |
| E.D. Louisiana, Jun 24, 2020 (No. 2:19-cv-13471) | $30,169.17 plus interest | $400 (of $3,800.67 actually incurred) | $400 | 1.33% of the benefit | Fifth Circuit standard of a modest award to a disinterested stakeholder |
The New Jersey opinion prints $4,570.40 in one sentence of its reasoning and $4,572.40 in its conclusion and in the relief requested; the table uses the conclusion. The Minnesota opinion's introduction gives $6,573.05, but its order and its instruction to the clerk both say $6,564.55, which is the figure above. Two other orders we read, from the District of Maryland in 2015 and the Southern District of Texas in 2014, held that the insurer was entitled to reasonable fees but left the amount to a later filing, so they have no row.
Why the amounts vary so much
The orders lean on a common test, set out in the Alabama order from Second Circuit authority: the insurer must be a disinterested stakeholder, must have conceded liability, must have deposited the disputed funds, and must have sought a discharge. Meeting the test makes an award possible, not automatic. The variations that follow are what moved the dollar figures.
- The circuit. The Eleventh Circuit (Alabama, Florida, Georgia) holds that fees are "not warranted" when the interpleader arises out of the normal course of business, and the Alabama order notes that this exception "typically is applied to insurance companies." The Minnesota court acknowledged that some courts deny fees on that reasoning and awarded them anyway.
- The scope of the work. Courts pay only for work on the interpleader itself. The Arkansas court refused the insurer's 26.6 hours on its own fee motion; Minnesota refused $1,212 of fee-motion time for the same reason.
- The billing. Redacted entries that hide what the lawyer did are struck. Minnesota removed $1,730 that way.
- The hourly rate. Missouri cut rates it found too high for "simple tasks"; Arkansas set a $250 blended rate.
- The size of the fund. The Arkansas order quotes the older rule that interpleader "does not usually involve any great amount of skill, labor or responsibility" and that fees "should be modest." The two smallest funds in the table, $39,250 and $30,169.17, produced both the highest share (11.65 percent in New Jersey) and the lowest share above zero (1.33 percent in Louisiana).
- The insurer's own conduct. The New Jersey opinion quotes the Wright and Miller treatise: the test is not met "if the stakeholder has contributed to the need for interpleader by acting in bad faith or by unduly delaying in seeking relief." It found no such evidence there.
Who pays is a separate decision from how much. The Minnesota order calls payment out of the interpleaded fund "the typical practice of federal courts," while noting that a court may instead "tax the losing claimant directly" when that claimant's conduct justifies it, which usually requires a finding of bad faith.
A $400,000 deposit, followed to the payout
Here is how the charges stack up on one hypothetical claim. The inputs are stated so any of them can be swapped for real numbers from a court file.
- Death benefit deposited: $400,000.
- Insurer fee award: $10,194.30, the amount the Arkansas court allowed in 2013, paid out of the fund at discharge.
- Time in the registry after the fee is paid: 15 months (1.25 years).
- Yield on the registry investment: a hypothetical 0, 2 or 4 percent a year, simple interest. These are illustrations, not forecasts of what any registry account will earn.
- Registry fee: 0.20 percent a year of assets on deposit, taken from interest, per the fee schedule effective December 1, 2023.
- Fund income tax: 37 percent of the interest left after the registry fee. That treats the whole amount as falling in the top bracket and the fee as reducing taxable interest, a simplification; the fund's administrator prepares the real return.
| Step | 0% yield | 2% yield | 4% yield |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deposit | $400,000.00 | $400,000.00 | $400,000.00 |
| Less insurer fee award | $10,194.30 | $10,194.30 | $10,194.30 |
| Principal left in the registry | $389,805.70 | $389,805.70 | $389,805.70 |
| Interest over 15 months | $0.00 | $9,745.14 | $19,490.29 |
| Less registry fee (0.20% a year on $389,805.70) | $0.00 | $974.51 | $974.51 |
| Less fund tax at 37% | $0.00 | $3,245.13 | $6,850.84 |
| Paid to the winning side | $389,805.70 | $395,331.20 | $401,470.64 |
| Change from the $400,000 benefit | minus $10,194.30 | minus $4,668.80 | plus $1,470.64 |
The middle column, worked by hand: $389,805.70 times 2 percent times 1.25 years is $9,745.14 of interest. The registry fee is $389,805.70 times 0.20 percent times 1.25, or $974.51. That leaves $8,770.63, and 37 percent of it is $3,245.13 in fund tax. The $5,525.50 left after tax, added to the $389,805.70 principal, is $395,331.20.
Two things show up in the table. At a 4 percent yield, the after-tax interest ($11,664.94) is larger than the fee award ($10,194.30), so the deposit ends slightly above the face amount. At 0 or 2 percent, the claimants collectively lose money compared with an undisputed claim. None of these columns includes the claimants' own lawyers, who are paid by the people who hired them, not from the insurer's award. No order we read states what the claimants spent, so it is left out of the arithmetic, but it comes on top of every figure above and grows with each month the case stays contested.
Compare the settled version of the same claim. If both claimants sign an agreement before the insurer files, the insurer can pay the $400,000 directly, split as the agreement says, and the state's claim-payment interest statute may add interest from the date of death or proof of loss. Our guide to a life insurance claim that is taking too long lists nine states' interest rules, including the Texas 90-day limit on paying or interpleading after an adverse claim and New York's interest rule for interpleaded proceeds.
How long an interpleader takes, from the orders' own dates
No statute or rule sets a deadline for resolving a federal interpleader, so the honest answer is that it varies. The orders do record dates, though, and they give a sense of the range. Every interval below runs to the order that discharged the insurer or set its fees, which is not always the end of the claimants' dispute.
| Court | Dates in the order | Interval | Where the case stood |
|---|---|---|---|
| S.D. Alabama | Death Oct 6, 2007; complaint Apr 25, 2008; deposit May 13, 2008; order Nov 13, 2008 | About 13 months from death to the order | Insurer discharged; claimants' case stayed while a criminal case against one claimant was pending, with status reports every 60 days |
| E.D. Missouri | Death May 2, 2012; order Jan 29, 2013 | About 9 months | Insurer discharged; claims among the remaining defendants continued |
| D. Minnesota | Death Jul 29, 2011; first claim Aug 29, 2011; insurer's settlement letter Feb 9, 2012; complaint Mar 6, 2012; order Mar 27, 2013 | About 20 months | Fees paid from the registry; claims of a former spouse and three daughters continued |
| E.D. Arkansas | Deposit Jun 21, 2012; fee order May 10, 2013 | About 11 months from deposit | A criminal charge against the beneficiary was pending |
| S.D. Texas | Death Jun 24, 2012; order Mar 6, 2014 | About 20 months | $100,000 ordered into an interest-bearing registry account; insurer dismissed; undue influence claims continued |
| S.D. Ohio | Death Feb 14, 2015; insurer terminated Aug 12, 2016; deposit Nov 17, 2016; ruling Jan 11, 2017 | About 23 months | Claims decided, with a funeral financing claim of $20,793.71 still open before disbursement |
| D. New Jersey | Death Apr 1, 2016; motion Feb 23, 2017; order Sep 8, 2017 | About 17 months | Interpleader granted; neither claimant had answered the complaint |
| D. Maryland | Death Sep 7, 2012; order granting leave to deposit Aug 18, 2015 | About 35 months | The deposit came only after a claim against the insurer was dismissed |
Eight cases are not a sample of anything, and every interval in the table is shaped by facts the families could not change: criminal charges, guardianships, an unanswered complaint. The pattern they do show is that the insurer's part usually ends within a year or two of the death, while the claimants' part runs on its own schedule. A criminal case can freeze a civil one; our guide to the slayer rule and life insurance explains why insurers withhold payment while a beneficiary is under investigation.
The disputes that end up in interpleader
The orders above also show which conflicts push an insurer to court. Several recur often enough to plan for.
- A former spouse still named. In the Minnesota case, a 1983 policy named the insured's spouse; the couple divorced in 1986, the designation was never changed, and his three daughters claimed under California probate law. Our guide to life insurance after divorce explains how decrees, state revocation statutes and employer plans treat an old designation.
- A late change of beneficiary. The Texas case turned on a designation signed two weeks before the insured's death, challenged as undue influence. The Maryland case involved a designation changed online. The New Jersey dispute pitted the insured's spouse, through a guardian, against a girlfriend named by a telephone change. A change made correctly leaves less to argue about; see how to change a life insurance beneficiary.
- A beneficiary accused in the death. Alabama and Arkansas both involved beneficiaries facing criminal charges, and both cases waited on the criminal court.
- Deaths close together. When an insured and a beneficiary die in the same event, the order of death decides which estate takes, and that question can go to a court; see simultaneous death and life insurance.
- A creditor of the claim. The Ohio case included a funeral financing company that claimed part of the proceeds for the funeral it had financed. Families weighing that kind of arrangement can compare options in paying for a funeral before life insurance pays.
An interpleader is different from a denial. If the insurer says no benefit is payable at all, because of a contestability review, an exclusion or a lapse, the fight is with the insurer, and the steps in appealing a denied life insurance claim apply instead.
Before the insurer files: a settlement checklist for rival claimants
Insurers commonly write to rival claimants before filing. The Minnesota insurer's lawyer wrote that "if you cannot reach an agreement between yourselves as to how the policy proceeds should be paid, my client will have no choice but to interplead the policy proceeds into court." The New Jersey insurer told the claimants that an interpleader "could entitle" it to costs and fees, and the judge counted that warning in its favor. That letter opens the cheapest window the claimants will have. These are the steps that use it, offered as education rather than legal advice.
- Write down the deadline. Ask the insurer in writing how long it will hold the claim before filing, and whether it will pay on a signed agreement among all claimants. Keep the answer.
- Get the documents that decide the claim. The current beneficiary designation and any earlier ones, the change-of-beneficiary records with dates and method (paper, online, telephone), any divorce decree or settlement, the death certificate, and for group coverage the plan document. Rival claimants who look at the same papers often find that one claim is much weaker than it seemed.
- Name every possible claimant. An agreement among two people does not bind a third. Contingent beneficiaries, the estate's personal representative, a guardian for a minor or an incapacitated spouse, and a funeral lender with a claim on the proceeds may each need to sign.
- Price the alternative honestly. Use the arithmetic above with your own figures: the benefit, a fee award in the range courts have allowed, months in the registry, and above all each side's own lawyer costs. A split that looks unfair in principle can still leave both sides with more than a contested case would.
- Put the agreement in writing with every signature. It should state each claimant's dollar or percentage share, release the others' claims to the benefit, and give the insurer what it needs to pay without risk of a second claim. Ask the insurer what form of release it will accept.
- Clear the capacity problems first. A minor cannot sign a binding release, and an estate cannot act until a personal representative is appointed. Our page on naming a minor as beneficiary covers guardianship and custodianship.
- Know which disputes are hard to settle by agreement. Where a claimant is charged in the insured's death, the civil case may wait: the Alabama court stayed the claimants' case until the criminal case ended. For group plans governed by ERISA, the plan document controls who is paid, so ask the plan administrator in writing how it treats an agreement among claimants.
- If the case is filed anyway, read the fee request. In the Missouri, Minnesota and Arkansas orders, courts cut the insurer's request by about 31, 38 and 58 percent for high rates, fee-motion time and redacted or unrelated entries. Claimants can object: in Missouri, the claimants challenged the rates as excessive, and the court cut the request from $24,623.81 to $17,037.
A licensed attorney in the state whose law governs the policy is the right person to judge the strength of a claim or draft a release. The checklist only marks the decisions that come up.
After the deposit: what claimants should watch for
Once the insurer is out of the case, the claimants carry it. Answer the complaint by the deadline on the summons; in the New Jersey case neither claimant had answered when the judge granted interpleader relief, and a default can decide the outcome against a silent claimant. Ask the clerk or the docket whether the deposit was invested in an interest-bearing account, since Rule 67(b) requires it. Keep track of the insurer's fee request and the deadline to object to it. When a settlement or judgment is reached, submit a proposed disbursement order; several of the orders above direct a party to prepare one, and the clerk will not pay without it.
Related claim problems, from a slow insurer to a disputed designation, are covered in the claims and beneficiaries guides. A claimant who wins should expect a payment of principal and the interest left after the registry fee and the fund's tax, and may receive tax paperwork from the fund's administrator.
Sources
- Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives, 28 U.S.C. 1335, Interpleader, checked October 31, 2026: $500 threshold, diverse adverse claimants, deposit or bond, subsection (b).
- Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 28 U.S.C. 1397, checked October 31, 2026: venue in any district where a claimant resides.
- Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 28 U.S.C. 2361, Process and procedure, checked October 31, 2026: nationwide process, restraining orders, discharge.
- Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 28 U.S.C. 1332, checked October 31, 2026: $75,000 diversity threshold.
- Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 28 U.S.C. 2041 and 28 U.S.C. 2042, checked October 31, 2026: deposit of registry money; withdrawal only by court order; five-year unclaimed rule.
- Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (December 1, 2025 edition), checked October 31, 2026: Rule 22, Interpleader; Rule 67, Deposit into Court.
- Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, District Court Miscellaneous Fee Schedule, effective December 1, 2023, checked October 31, 2026: registry fees of 10 and 20 basis points.
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 26 CFR 1.468B-9, Disputed ownership funds, checked October 31, 2026: definition, paragraph (c) taxation, Example 3.
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 26 CFR 1.468B-2, Taxation of qualified settlement funds, checked October 31, 2026: paragraph (a) tax rate.
- Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 26 U.S.C. 1, checked October 31, 2026: subsection (j)(2)(E) rate table for estates and trusts.
- American General Life Ins. Co. v. Jones, No. 1:08-cv-00211 (S.D. Ala. Nov. 13, 2008), order, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Transamerica Life Ins. Co. v. Lambert, No. 4:12-cv-01253 (E.D. Mo. Jan. 29, 2013), memorandum and order, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Protective Life Ins. Co. v. Kridner, No. 0:12-cv-00582 (D. Minn. Mar. 27, 2013), memorandum opinion and order on attorneys' fees and costs, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Despain v. Northwestern Mutual Life Ins. Co., No. 3:12-cv-00105 (E.D. Ark. May 10, 2013), order, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Southern Farm Bureau Life Ins. Co. v. Lusk, No. 4:13-cv-00847 (S.D. Tex. Mar. 6, 2014), opinion and order, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Gray, No. 8:13-cv-01956 (D. Md. Aug. 18, 2015), memorandum opinion, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Minnesota Life Ins. Co. v. Birney, No. 2:15-cv-02693 (S.D. Ohio Jan. 11, 2017), opinion and order, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Teixeira, No. 2:16-cv-07486 (D.N.J. Sep. 8, 2017), opinion, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
- Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Hartmann, No. 2:19-cv-13471 (E.D. La. June 24, 2020), order and reasons, govinfo, checked October 31, 2026.
Questions claimants ask once an interpleader is on the table
What is a life insurance interpleader?
It is a lawsuit an insurer files when two or more people claim the same death benefit. The insurer deposits the benefit with the court, names the claimants as defendants, asks to be discharged from further liability, and the court decides who is paid. In federal court it can be brought under 28 U.S.C. 1335 or under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 22.
Can the insurer take its attorney fees out of the death benefit?
Often, yes, if the court allows it. In seven federal orders from 2008 to 2020, courts allowed insurers between $400 and $17,037 from the fund, and one court in the Eleventh Circuit denied fees entirely because competing claims are a normal part of the insurance business. Courts limit fees to work on the interpleader itself and frequently cut the amount requested.
How long does a life insurance interpleader take?
No rule sets a deadline, so it varies. In seven federal cases we read that give a date of death, the order discharging the insurer, setting its fees or allowing the deposit came between about 9 and 35 months after the death, and in several the claimants' dispute continued after that. Criminal charges, guardianships and unanswered complaints all lengthened the cases.
Does the money earn interest while it is in the court registry?
It must be placed in an interest-bearing account or instrument under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 67(b). The court takes a fee from the interest, 0.20 percent a year of assets for section 1335 funds in the Disputed Ownership Fund under the fee schedule effective December 1, 2023, and the fund itself is taxed on its interest under Treasury Regulation 1.468B-9.
Can the claimants settle and get paid without going to court?
Yes, if every person with a possible claim signs a written agreement the insurer will accept. Insurers commonly write to rival claimants asking them to agree before filing. Once a case is filed, a settlement still needs a court order before the clerk releases the money, because 28 U.S.C. 2042 allows withdrawal only by order of court.
Do I have to answer an interpleader complaint?
Yes. A claimant named as a defendant should respond by the deadline on the summons and state their claim to the fund. A claimant who stays silent risks a default, which can leave the money to the other side.
Can I sue the insurer after it files an interpleader?
In a statutory interpleader under 28 U.S.C. 1335, the court can order claimants not to sue the insurer in any state or federal court over the benefit, and it can make that order permanent when it discharges the insurer. That power under 28 U.S.C. 2361 is not available in a Rule 22 interpleader, as a 2008 Alabama order held.