Claims and beneficiaries
When a Beneficiary Kills the Insured: The Slayer Rule and Who Gets the Payout
Claims and beneficiaries · Updated October 31, 2026
A beneficiary who intentionally and unlawfully kills the insured forfeits the death benefit. Every state slayer statute read for this guide says so, and federal courts apply the same rule to workplace plans and federal group coverage. The money is then paid as if the killer had no claim: to a contingent beneficiary if the policy names one, and otherwise to the insured's estate, the nearest relative, or whoever a court decides is entitled, depending on the state. A criminal conviction is not always needed. In most of the states below, a civil court can decide the question on a preponderance of the evidence, even after an acquittal or when no charge is ever filed.
Texas puts the whole rule in two sentences of its Insurance Code. Section 1103.151 says a beneficiary "forfeits the beneficiary's interest in the policy or contract if the beneficiary is a principal or an accomplice in wilfully bringing about the death of the insured." Section 1103.152 then sends the proceeds to a contingent beneficiary named by the insured, unless that person is also implicated, and if no contingent is entitled, to "the nearest relative of the insured." Other states use different words for the conduct, a different standard of proof, and a different fallback when nobody else is named. Those three differences decide who is paid, and they are laid out below.
Sources and dates: how we check each figure.
Nine slayer statutes on one page
The table sets out what each statute requires and where the money goes. Each row was read on the state legislature's own site on October 31, 2026. California is not included: its official code site did not serve the text for this review, so California readers should read Probate Code sections 250 to 259 on leginfo.legislature.ca.gov or ask a California attorney.
| State and statute | Conduct that forfeits the benefit | Without a conviction | Manslaughter in the text? | Who receives the proceeds instead |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Texas, Insurance Code 1103.151 to 1103.152 | Principal or accomplice "in wilfully bringing about the death" | The chapter states no proof standard; a court decides | Not named | Contingent beneficiary named by the insured; if none is entitled, the "nearest relative of the insured" |
| Washington, RCW 11.84.010 to 11.84.140 | Principal or accessory before the fact in the "willful and unlawful killing" | Superior court finding by a preponderance of the evidence | Not named | Secondary beneficiary (anyone other than the slayer or the slayer's estate); otherwise the decedent's estate |
| Virginia, Code 64.2-2500 to 64.2-2511 | Murder or voluntary manslaughter of the decedent | Court finding by a preponderance of the evidence; burden on the party alleging the slaying | Yes: voluntary manslaughter only | Alternative beneficiary named in the policy; otherwise the decedent's estate |
| Florida, Statutes 732.802 | Unlawfully and intentionally kills, or participates in procuring the death | Court finding by "the greater weight of the evidence" | Not named; a murder conviction "in any degree" is conclusive | Payable "as though the killer had predeceased the decedent" |
| Minnesota, Statutes 524.2-803 | Feloniously and intentionally kills | Court finding by a preponderance of evidence | Not named | Insurer withholds on notice; a district court orders payment to "any person equitably entitled" |
| Oregon, ORS 112.455 to 112.555 | With felonious intent takes or procures the taking of a life; also guilty or responsible except for insanity | Court finding by a preponderance of evidence | Not named | Secondary beneficiary; otherwise the personal representative of the estate |
| Arizona, Revised Statutes 14-2803 | Homicide under sections 13-1103 (manslaughter), 13-1104 or 13-1105, including a finding of guilty except insane | Court determines, by a preponderance of the evidence, whether the person would be found criminally accountable | Yes: section 13-1103 is in the definition | The designation is revoked, and the policy is read as if the killer disclaimed |
| Michigan, MCL 700.2803 | Feloniously and intentionally kills; also a conviction for abuse, neglect or exploitation of the decedent | Court determines, by a preponderance of the evidence, whether the person would be found criminally accountable | Not named | The designation is revoked, and the policy is read as if the killer disclaimed |
| Illinois, 755 ILCS 5/2-6 | Intentionally and unjustifiably causes the death | Any court of competent jurisdiction, separate from the criminal case, after it ends or one year after death if no charge | Not named; first or second degree murder conviction is a conclusive presumption | Passes "as if the person causing the death died before the decedent" |
Source: the nine statutes as published on each legislature's official site (links in the Sources list), checked October 31, 2026. The table summarizes; the statute text controls.
Two patterns stand out. First, a conviction helps but is not required in eight of the nine rows: Washington, Virginia, Florida, Minnesota, Oregon, Arizona, Michigan and Illinois all let a civil court decide, and seven of them name the civil standard as a preponderance of the evidence or, in Florida's words, the greater weight of the evidence. Texas is silent on the standard. Second, the fallback is where states part ways. Texas skips the estate and goes to the nearest relative; Washington and Virginia go to the estate; Minnesota hands the decision to a judge.
Manslaughter, insanity and the exact words of each statute
Families often ask whether a manslaughter plea saves the killer's claim. The statutes answer in their verbs, and the verbs differ.
Virginia names its line. The definition of "slayer" in section 64.2-2500 covers a person convicted of "the murder or voluntary manslaughter of the decedent," or found by a court to have committed one of those offenses. Voluntary manslaughter is in; involuntary manslaughter is not on the list.
Arizona's list reaches further. Section 14-2803 defines "felonious and intentional" as a conviction or a finding of guilty except insane for a homicide under sections 13-1103, 13-1104 or 13-1105. Section 13-1103 is Arizona's manslaughter statute, and its first paragraph is "Recklessly causing the death of another person." On the text, a manslaughter conviction under that section falls inside the slayer definition, even though the heading of 14-2803 speaks of murder.
The other seven use intent words. Washington requires a "willful and unlawful killing." Florida requires a killing that is "unlawful and intentional." Minnesota, Oregon and Michigan use "feloniously and intentionally" or "felonious intent." Illinois requires that the person "intentionally and unjustifiably" caused the death. Texas uses "wilfully bringing about." None of those seven statutes mentions manslaughter by name. Whether a particular manslaughter conviction meets an intent requirement depends on the facts and the state's case law, and this guide does not predict how any court would rule. What the text does show is that a conviction for a lesser offense does not end the inquiry: the civil court can still hear evidence about intent.
Insanity is handled by name in three states. Washington treats a finding of not guilty by reason of insanity as carrying "the same meaning as a judgment of conviction." Oregon's definition of slayer includes a person "found guilty except for insanity" or, for a youth, "responsible except for insanity." Arizona's definition includes a finding of "guilty except insane." In those states, an insanity outcome in the criminal case does not return the benefit to the killer. The other statutes read here do not address insanity in their text.
Helpers count too. Texas reaches an "accomplice," Washington an "accessory before the fact," Florida anyone who "participates in procuring the death," and Oregon anyone who "procures the taking" of a life. A beneficiary who hired or helped the killer is treated as the killer for the payout.
Predeceased, disclaimed, or sent to a judge: where the money lands
Once a beneficiary is disqualified, each statute uses one of four methods to pick the next recipient. The method matters most when the policy names no contingent beneficiary, or when the contingent beneficiaries are the killer's own relatives.
- Treat the killer as having died first. Florida's subsection (3) makes the policy "payable as though the killer had predeceased the decedent," and Illinois says the benefit "shall pass as if the person causing the death died before the decedent." The policy's own terms then run as written: the contingent beneficiary takes, and if there is none, the contract's default clause decides. Many contracts default to the insured's estate, but the contract, not this guide, is the authority on that.
- Read the designation as disclaimed. Arizona and Michigan revoke the designation and give the policy effect "as if the killer disclaimed" the revoked provisions. The statutes use the word "disclaimed," and the "predeceased" fiction in those two statutes applies only to nominations as executor, trustee or agent. If the designation has a per stirpes clause that could pass a share to the killer's children, ask a lawyer in that state how the disclaimer route treats it.
- Name the next stop directly. Texas: contingent beneficiary, then the nearest relative. Washington and Virginia: secondary or alternative beneficiary, then the estate. Oregon: secondary beneficiary, then the personal representative of the estate (or of an heir or devisee, where the proceeds came through one). The Texas chapter does not define "nearest relative," which can itself lead to a court case among family members.
- Let a court decide. Minnesota is the outlier. When the insurer receives written notice at its home office that the insured may have been killed by a named beneficiary, it "shall, pending court order, withhold payment of the policy proceeds to all beneficiaries." Any interested party can then sue in district court, and the court "may order the insurance company to pay the policy proceeds to any person equitably entitled thereto, including the deceased insured's spouse, children, issue, parents, creditors or estate." A contingent beneficiary in Minnesota has a strong claim but no automatic one.
The estate route keeps the killer out in a second way. Washington's RCW 11.84.030 and Virginia's 64.2-2502 also treat the slayer as having predeceased the decedent for intestate succession and a surviving spouse's statutory rights. So when life insurance falls into the estate, a spouse who killed the insured cannot collect it again as an heir. The cost of the estate route is probate time and exposure to the decedent's debts: money paid to an estate can be reached by estate creditors in a way that money paid to a named person often cannot, as our guide to creditors and life insurance payouts explains state by state.
Two states extend the forfeiture to relatives in a narrow way. For intestate succession, Virginia says an heir who establishes kinship to the decedent through the slayer is "deemed to be claiming from the decedent and not through the slayer," which protects, for example, a child of the killer and the victim who inherits from the victim's estate. Federal SGLI rules, covered below, go the other direction for one group: relatives of the killer who are not related to the victim by blood, adoption or marriage are barred too.
One policy, two designations, five states
A hypothetical shows how far the result can move. Dana owns a $400,000 term policy on her own life and names her husband, Sam, as sole primary beneficiary. A court later finds by a preponderance of the evidence that Sam intentionally killed Dana; he was never convicted. Dana leaves two children under 18 and a mother. The table runs two versions: one where Dana named her sister as contingent beneficiary, and one where she named no contingent at all.
| State | Version A: sister named as contingent | Version B: no contingent named |
|---|---|---|
| Texas | Sister, under 1103.152(a) | "Nearest relative of the insured," undefined in the chapter; a court may have to decide between the children and others |
| Washington | Sister, as secondary beneficiary under RCW 11.84.100(1) | Dana's estate, through probate; Sam is treated as predeceased for inheritance too |
| Virginia | Sister, as alternative beneficiary under 64.2-2508(A) | Dana's estate, through probate |
| Florida | Sister, because the policy pays as though Sam died first | Whoever the contract's default clause names when no beneficiary survives, often the estate |
| Minnesota | Insurer withholds on notice; a court orders payment to a person equitably entitled, and the sister is one candidate among the children and others | Same court process; the statute lists spouse, children, issue, parents, creditors or estate as possible recipients |
Hypothetical illustration built by TrueLifeCost from the statute text; names and amounts are invented, and the face amount does not change the routing. In version A, four of the five states pay the sister. In version B, four different answers appear. If the children end up as recipients, a guardian or trust usually has to be in place before an insurer will pay them, which our guide to naming a minor as beneficiary covers. The practical lesson for any policy owner is in column A: a named contingent beneficiary, who is not the primary's relative or dependent on the primary, is what makes the outcome predictable. Our primer on primary and contingent beneficiaries walks through how the layers work.
Before any verdict: notice, withholding and the waiting period
Slayer claims often sit unpaid for months or years, because the criminal case comes first and the civil finding follows. Several statutes speak directly to what the insurer does in the meantime.
| State | What the statute says about the insurer before a ruling |
|---|---|
| Texas, 1103.102(b) | The insurer is "not required to pay" the designated beneficiary if it receives notice of an adverse claim from a person with "a bona fide legal claim" to the proceeds |
| Minnesota, 524.2-803(d) | On written notice at its home office, the insurer must withhold payment to all beneficiaries pending a court order; without notice, payment already made discharges it |
| Florida, 732.802(6) | The insurer is not liable for paying under the policy terms unless, before payment, it received written notice of a claim at its home office or principal address |
| Washington, RCW 11.84.110 | No added liability for a payment made without written notice of the killing at the home office or at an individual's home or business address |
| Arizona, 14-2803(G) and (H) | Notice must go by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the payor's main office, or be served like a summons; after notice the payor may deposit the money with the court |
| Illinois, 755 ILCS 5/2-6 | A holder is not liable for paying the person who caused the death before a determination; the civil case cannot go to trial until the criminal case is decided, or for one year after death if no charge is brought |
| Virginia, 64.2-2508(D) | No added liability for a payment made without notice of the circumstances |
Source: statute text as listed, checked October 31, 2026.
The common thread is written notice. Several of these statutes protect an insurer that pays the named beneficiary before anyone tells it, in writing, at the right address, that the beneficiary is implicated. A family member who believes the beneficiary caused the death should not assume the police report reaches the insurer. Send a written notice of the claim to the insurer's home office, by certified mail with a return receipt, and keep the proof. Once two sides claim the same money, many insurers file an interpleader and deposit the proceeds with a court, which ends the insurer's role and starts the court's; the deadlines and interest rules that apply while that happens are in our guide to a life insurance claim that is taking too long.
Virginia adds a rule worth knowing in cases where the insured and the beneficiary both die. Section 64.2-2511(C) says the Uniform Simultaneous Death Act "shall not apply to cases governed by this chapter," so the slayer chapter, not the 120-hour survival rule, decides a murder-suicide in Virginia. The survival rules that apply to accidents and common disasters are covered in our guide to when the insured and the beneficiary die at the same time.
Workplace plans under ERISA: what the Sixth Circuit held in 2024
Life insurance provided through a private employer is usually governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), a federal law that overrides many state rules about beneficiaries. In 2001, in Egelhoff v. Egelhoff, the Supreme Court held that ERISA preempted a state law that revoked an ex-spouse's beneficiary status on divorce, but it expressly left open whether state slayer statutes survive. That gap is why families with workplace coverage sometimes hear that the state slayer law "may not apply."
The Sixth Circuit's August 19, 2024 decision in the Guy case answered the practical question without resolving the legal one. A son was convicted of the first degree premeditated murder of both parents, a crime the court described as having an expressly financial motive, and then claimed his mother's employer life and accidental death plans. The court affirmed that he could not collect, holding that "we need not definitively resolve the preemption issue left open in Egelhoff." Either Tennessee's slayer statute applied, or, if ERISA preempted it, federal common law supplied the same rule. The court noted that the only other circuit to decide the point, the Seventh Circuit in 2018, had held that ERISA does not preempt state slayer statutes at all.
For the federal common-law rule, the court relied on an 1886 Supreme Court decision holding that "it would be a reproach to the jurisprudence of the country if one could recover insurance money payable on the death of the party whose life he had feloniously taken." It quoted the Supreme Court's own description of the slayer principle as "adopted by nearly every State," and listed federal decisions applying it to Servicemembers' Group Life Insurance and to Federal Employees' Group Life Insurance. In the Guy case itself, disqualification moved the mother's death benefits to the killer's aunt and uncle, the people next in line under the plan documents as the district court read them.
Two states have written a backstop for the case where federal law displaces their statute. Virginia's 64.2-2511(B) and Arizona's 14-2803(J) both say that if the statute is preempted, a person who received a payment "not for value" that they would not be entitled to under the state rule must return it or is personally liable for its value. So even if a plan pays the named beneficiary under federal law, the state may still let the rightful recipient sue the person who received it. For the other ways workplace coverage differs from an individual policy, see our guide to gaps in employer group life.
SGLI and VGLI: the federal regulation spells it out
Servicemembers' Group Life Insurance and Veterans' Group Life Insurance do not leave the question to state law or court-made rules. The Department of Veterans Affairs regulation at 38 CFR 9.5(e), read in the eCFR on October 31, 2026, sets its own rule, and it is broader than most state statutes in three ways.
- Who is barred. The proceeds "shall not be payable" to a person convicted of intentionally and wrongfully killing the decedent or determined in a civil proceeding to have done so; to a person convicted of, or found in a civil proceeding to have, assisted or aided that person; and to "a member of the family" of either one "who is not related to the decedent by blood, legal adoption, or marriage." Section 9.1(l) defines that family to include the killer's spouse, children, parents, siblings, grandparents and grandchildren, including step and adoptive relatives. The same bar applies to the SGLI Traumatic Injury Protection benefit.
- An appeal does not pause it. Under 9.5(e)(3), the bar holds "even though the criminal conviction or civil determination is pending appeal."
- A fixed order of payment. Under 9.5(e)(4), the money goes to the first surviving person or group in this order: the next eligible beneficiary the decedent designated in writing received by the uniformed service (or the VGLI administrative office) before death; the widow or widower; the children in equal shares, with descendants of deceased children taking by representation; the parents in equal shares or the survivor; the executor or administrator of the estate; and finally other next of kin under the law of the decedent's domicile. Payment to a person in that order "shall bar recovery of those proceeds" by anyone else.
The family-member clause closes a route the state statutes mostly leave open. A killer's child from another relationship, named as contingent beneficiary on an individual policy in Washington, would take as the secondary beneficiary; on SGLI, that child is barred, because the child is not related to the servicemember by blood, adoption or marriage. Our comparison of SGLI and VGLI with private term coverage covers how those programs work in other respects. Federal Employees' Group Life Insurance has its own statutory order of payment in 5 U.S.C. 8705, set out in the simultaneous-death guide linked above, and federal courts have applied the slayer principle to it as well.
Cases the forfeiture does not reach, and two it reaches unexpectedly
The slayer rule is aimed at intentional, wrongful killing, and the federal common-law version described in the Guy decision carries stated limits. Quoting a 1959 Sixth Circuit decision, the court said the common law prevents the beneficiary from taking "unless the beneficiary was insane at the time, or the killing was accidental, or was committed in self-defense." State statutes reach the same ground through their own words: "unlawful," "felonious," and "unjustifiably" exclude lawful self-defense by their terms, and a purely accidental death is not willful or intentional. The insanity exception is where state and federal rules can differ, since Washington, Oregon and Arizona count insanity findings as slayer findings in their statutes.
A killing that is ruled lawful or accidental leaves the beneficiary designation in force, and the claim then runs like any other death claim, including the contestability review if the policy is under two years old. If the insurer denies a claim on slayer grounds and the beneficiary disputes the facts, the appeal and complaint routes in our guide to appealing a denied claim apply, alongside the court process the statute sets.
A policy bought as part of the plan. Virginia's 64.2-2508(C) goes further than redirecting the money. No insurer is liable at all on a policy on the decedent's life if the slayer procured and maintained it as part of a plan to murder the decedent, and the death resulted from an act within two years of the policy's issue date. In that case there is no payout to redirect to anyone.
Policies on the killer's own life. Washington, Virginia and Oregon also address the reverse situation: the victim was the beneficiary of a policy insuring the killer. When the killer later dies, those proceeds go to the victim's estate, unless the policy names someone other than the killer or the killer's estate as secondary beneficiary, or the killer validly changed the beneficiary in a way that would have cut out the victim anyway. Families settling an estate after a homicide should look for these policies too.
Abuse and exploitation. Three states stretch the statute past killing. Washington's "Carol's law" covers an "abuser" who financially exploited the decedent while the decedent was a vulnerable adult, proven by clear, cogent and convincing evidence, unless the decedent knew and later ratified the gift. Oregon applies its chapter to a person convicted of a felony for physical or financial abuse of the decedent, if the decedent dies within five years after the conviction. Michigan applies its forfeiture to a person convicted of abuse, neglect or exploitation of the decedent, unless the decedent signed a new instrument after the conviction showing a specific intent to let that person inherit. In those states, a caregiver beneficiary convicted of exploitation can lose a life insurance payout even though the death itself was natural.
Mapping the payout: a decision flow for families
The sequence below follows the questions a court and an insurer ask, in the order they usually arise. It is a map for conversations with the insurer and a lawyer, not a prediction of any case.
- Is the coverage individual, a private employer plan, or federal? SGLI and VGLI follow 38 CFR 9.5(e) and its fixed order. FEGLI follows 5 U.S.C. 8705. A private employer plan follows the plan document and either the state slayer statute or the federal common-law rule; as the Guy decision shows, the result for a convicted murderer is the same either way. An individual policy follows the state statute, usually that of the insured's home state, though the contract or a court may point elsewhere.
- Has the insurer received written notice? If not, send it now, by certified mail to the home office, naming the claim and the reason. In Minnesota that notice triggers mandatory withholding; in Florida, Washington, Arizona and Virginia it ends the insurer's protection for paying the named beneficiary.
- Is there a conviction? A final conviction for the listed offense is conclusive in most of the nine states (Arizona, Michigan and Oregon require that appeals be exhausted first). If there is no conviction, or there was an acquittal, an interested person can usually ask a civil court to decide on the lower standard. In Illinois, that civil case waits for the criminal case or for one year after death.
- Is a contingent beneficiary named, and is that person untouched by the killing? In Texas, Washington, Virginia, Oregon, Florida and Illinois, an innocent contingent beneficiary is normally next. In Arizona and Michigan the policy is read as though the killer disclaimed. In Minnesota, the contingent still has to ask the court.
- If no contingent takes, what is the fallback? Texas: nearest relative. Washington and Virginia: the estate. Oregon: the personal representative. Florida and Illinois: the policy's own terms with the killer treated as predeceased. Minnesota: the court's equitable order. Arizona and Michigan: the policy read as if the killer disclaimed.
- If the money goes to the estate, who inherits? Open probate, and check that the killer is excluded as an heir too (Washington and Virginia say so expressly). Plan for estate creditors before distribution.
- If the recipient is a minor, arrange a guardian of the estate, a custodian or a trust before the insurer will release the funds.
The paperwork that moves a slayer claim
Slayer claims stall when nobody gives the insurer what the statute needs. The documents below are the ones a claimant other than the named beneficiary usually has to supply, along with the standard claim form and certified death certificate covered in our step-by-step guide to filing a life insurance claim.
- The written notice and its proof of delivery. Keep the certified mail receipt and a copy of the letter.
- Charging documents, if any. Minnesota's 524.2-803(h) lets the personal representative or an interested person file a copy of the complaint or indictment with the probate court, with an inventory of affected property, and ask for orders to protect it.
- The judgment of conviction, once final. Washington's RCW 11.84.130 and Virginia's 64.2-2510 make the conviction record admissible in the civil case, and Virginia calls a conviction "conclusive evidence of the guilt of the slayer."
- Letters of administration if the estate is the likely recipient, so a personal representative can claim on its behalf.
- The policy, every beneficiary form and any assignment, since the contingent designation and the contract's default clause decide most outcomes.
Our guide to life insurance after divorce covers a related situation, where a beneficiary named during a marriage may lose the benefit by statute after it ends. The beneficiary pages collected in the claims and beneficiaries hub sit alongside this one. Education only. This site does not sell insurance and does not provide quotes, and nothing here predicts how an insurer or a court will decide a particular claim. A family facing a slayer claim should speak with a probate or insurance attorney in the insured's state early, because the notice and court deadlines start before most families think about the policy.
For anyone reviewing their own coverage after reading this, the most useful step is small: open your policy's beneficiary page and check that a contingent beneficiary is named who would still be the right person if the primary could not take. The forms and timing for making that change are in our guide on how to change a life insurance beneficiary.
Sources
- Texas Legislature, Insurance Code chapter 1103, checked October 31, 2026: sections 1103.102(b), 1103.151 and 1103.152.
- Washington State Legislature, RCW chapter 11.84, Inheritance rights of slayers or abusers, checked October 31, 2026: sections 11.84.010, .020, .030, .100, .110, .130, .140, .150 and .170.
- Virginia General Assembly, Code of Virginia title 64.2, chapter 25, Slayers, checked October 31, 2026: sections 64.2-2500, 2502, 2508, 2510 and 2511.
- Florida Legislature, Florida Statutes 732.802, checked October 31, 2026.
- Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, Minnesota Statutes 524.2-803, checked October 31, 2026: paragraphs (d), (f), (g) and (h).
- Oregon State Legislature, ORS chapter 112, checked October 31, 2026: sections 112.455 to 112.555.
- Arizona State Legislature, Arizona Revised Statutes 14-2803 and 13-1103, checked October 31, 2026.
- Michigan Legislature, MCL 700.2803, checked October 31, 2026.
- Illinois General Assembly, 755 ILCS 5/2-6, checked October 31, 2026.
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 38 CFR part 9, Servicemembers' Group Life Insurance and Veterans' Group Life Insurance, checked October 31, 2026: sections 9.1(l) and 9.5(e).
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, Standard Insurance Co. v. Guy, No. 21-5562, 24a0185p.06, decided August 19, 2024, govinfo.gov copy of the opinion, checked October 31, 2026. The opinion discusses Egelhoff v. Egelhoff, 532 U.S. 141 (2001); Laborers' Pension Fund v. Miscevic, 880 F.3d 927 (7th Cir. 2018); Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Armstrong, 117 U.S. 591 (1886); and Shoemaker v. Shoemaker, 263 F.2d 931 (6th Cir. 1959).
Slayer rule questions, from the charge to the check
Can a beneficiary collect life insurance if they killed the insured?
Not if a court finds the killing was intentional and unlawful. Every state slayer statute reviewed for this guide (Texas, Washington, Virginia, Florida, Minnesota, Oregon, Arizona, Michigan and Illinois) forfeits the killer's share, and federal courts apply the same rule to employer plans, SGLI and FEGLI. The proceeds go to the next person entitled under the statute or the policy.
Does the beneficiary have to be convicted to lose the payout?
In eight of the nine states reviewed, no. Washington, Virginia, Florida, Minnesota, Oregon, Arizona, Michigan and Illinois let a civil court decide without a conviction, and most name the preponderance of the evidence standard. An acquittal in the criminal case does not stop that civil finding. Federal SGLI rules also bar a person found in a civil proceeding to have intentionally and wrongfully killed the insured.
Who gets the life insurance if the beneficiary is disqualified?
Normally a contingent beneficiary named in the policy who had no part in the killing. If none is named, it depends on the state: the nearest relative in Texas, the estate in Washington and Virginia, the personal representative in Oregon, the policy's own default terms in Florida and Illinois, and a court's equitable order in Minnesota. SGLI and VGLI follow a fixed federal order of precedence.
Does a manslaughter conviction count under the slayer rule?
It depends on the statute. Virginia covers voluntary manslaughter but not involuntary. Arizona's definition includes its manslaughter statute, section 13-1103. The other seven statutes reviewed use intent words such as willful, felonious and intentional, or intentionally and unjustifiably, and do not mention manslaughter; a civil court can still weigh the evidence on intent.
Does the slayer rule apply to life insurance through work?
Yes, in effect. In its 2024 Guy decision, the Sixth Circuit held that a convicted murderer could not collect employer plan benefits governed by ERISA: either the state slayer statute applied or, if ERISA preempted it, federal common law barred him. The court did not decide the preemption question, which the Supreme Court left open in 2001. The Seventh Circuit held in 2018 that ERISA does not preempt state slayer statutes.
Will the insurer hold the money while a murder case is pending?
Minnesota and Texas give the insurer grounds to hold it, but only after notice arrives. Minnesota requires an insurer that receives written notice at its home office to withhold payment pending a court order, and Texas lets an insurer hold payment after notice of a bona fide adverse claim. Florida, Washington, Arizona and Virginia protect an insurer that pays the named beneficiary before it receives notice, so send notice in writing by certified mail.