Skip to main content

Business owners

Key Person and Buy-Sell Life Insurance: Who Owns the Policy, Who Gets Paid, and What Connelly Changed

Tax, estate and benefits · Updated October 30, 2026

Key person insurance is a policy a business owns on someone whose death would cost it money; the business pays the premiums, which are not deductible, and collects the benefit. Buy-sell insurance funds an agreement to buy a deceased owner's share, either by the company (entity redemption) or by the other owners (cross-purchase). Since Connelly v. United States (2024), that choice can change estate tax value by millions.

This page explains how the structures work, what federal tax law says about each one, and where small businesses most often get the paperwork wrong. It works from the statute text, the IRS form that reports employer-owned coverage, and the Supreme Court opinion itself. It does not tell any business which structure to use. Ownership, entity type, state law and the wording of an agreement all change the answer, so the decision belongs with a business attorney and a CPA, and the policy itself with a licensed life insurance agent in your state. Education only. This site does not sell insurance and does not provide quotes.

Sources and dates: how we check each figure.

Two jobs, three structures

Business life insurance does one of two jobs. The first is replacing value: a business loses revenue, a lender relationship or a project when a particular person dies, and a policy on that person gives the business cash to absorb the loss. That is key person coverage. The second is buying out an owner: when an owner dies, the surviving owners usually want the shares, and the deceased owner's family usually wants cash rather than a minority stake in a company they do not run. A buy-sell agreement sets the terms of that sale in advance, and life insurance is a common way to make sure the money exists on the day it is needed.

The buyout job can be structured two ways, and a third, hybrid form combines them. The table below lines up the mechanics. Every tax entry comes from the Internal Revenue Code sections cited in the sources list at the end, read on the official U.S. Code site (uscode.house.gov) and checked October 30, 2026; the Connelly row comes from the opinion.

QuestionKey personEntity redemption buy-sellCross-purchase buy-sell
What the money is forAbsorbing the business's loss from one person's deathThe company buys back the deceased owner's sharesThe surviving owners buy the deceased owner's shares personally
Who owns the policyThe businessThe businessEach owner owns a policy on each other owner
Who pays the premiumThe businessThe businessEach owner, from personal funds or compensation
Who receives the benefitThe businessThe business, which then pays the estateThe surviving owner, who then pays the estate
Policies needed with N ownersOne per key personNN × (N − 1)
Premiums deductible?No: section 264(a)(1) bars a deduction when the payer is directly or indirectly a beneficiaryNo, for the same reasonNo: the owner paying is the beneficiary
Section 101(j) notice and consent applies?Yes, when the insured is an employee of the business on the issue dateYes, when the owner is also an employee, officer or directorGenerally no, because the business does not own the contract
Effect on the company's estate tax value after ConnellyProceeds received by the company add to its valueProceeds add to company value, and the redemption obligation does not offset them in the Connelly analysisProceeds go to the surviving owner, not the company, so they do not raise company value
Basis for the surviving ownerNot applicableThe survivor buys nothing, so the survivor's basis in shares does not riseThe survivor pays cash for shares, and section 1012 sets basis at cost

The agreement in the Connelly case was a hybrid: the surviving owner had an option to buy, and if he declined, the company was required to redeem. Hybrids preserve flexibility at the agreement stage, but whoever owns the policy decides where the money lands when someone dies. In Connelly the company owned the policies, so the tax result followed the entity-redemption column.

Key person coverage: sizing the loss before buying the policy

There is no statutory formula for how much key person insurance a business should carry, and no public source publishes a credible rule of thumb tied to a person's salary. A defensible amount comes from listing what the business would actually lose, the same discipline our guide to sizing personal coverage applies to a household. The components below are the ones that most often appear in a business's own reasoning. They are prompts for a worksheet, not a published method.

Loss componentWhere the figure comes fromQuestion to answer in writing
Lost gross profit during the vacancyYour own accounts: revenue the person originates or delivers, less the costs that would also stopHow many months until a replacement produces at the same level, and what profit is lost in those months?
Recruiting and onboardingSearch fees, signing terms and training time your business has actually paid beforeWhat did the last senior hire cost from opening the role to full productivity?
Debt the person securesLoan agreements and personal guaranteesDoes any lender require a policy, or would a lender call or reprice a loan if this person died?
Contracts tied to the personCustomer and supplier contracts, licences and certificationsDoes any contract name this person, or depend on a licence only this person holds?
Working capital bufferCash flow historyHow many months of fixed costs would the business want in reserve while it reorganises?

Worked example, labelled hypothetical. A design firm's lead architect originates work producing $300,000 a year of gross profit. The partners estimate nine months before a replacement produces at that level, so the vacancy loss is $300,000 × 9 ÷ 12 = $225,000. A senior search last cost the firm $60,000. A $150,000 equipment loan carries the architect's personal guarantee. (When a loan is SBA-guaranteed, the lender's life insurance condition follows a written collateral-shortfall formula, worked through in does an SBA loan require life insurance.) The firm wants three months of fixed costs, $40,000 a month, as a buffer: $120,000. The total is $225,000 + $60,000 + $150,000 + $120,000 = $555,000. Every input in that list is the firm's own number, which is the point: the figure can be explained to a lender, an auditor or the insured person, and it can be rerun when the business changes. Our coverage need calculator is built for households, but its add-the-lines logic works the same way if you treat each component as a line.

The coverage period follows the loss. A key person need usually ends when the person retires, leaves, or the business is sold, which points toward term coverage for many businesses, while a buyout obligation lasts as long as the ownership does. The trade-offs between temporary and lifetime coverage are set out in term vs whole life; the same structural logic applies when the owner of the policy is a company.

The tax rule that catches small businesses: section 101(j)

Most people know that life insurance death benefits are generally received free of federal income tax under section 101(a) of the Internal Revenue Code; our guide to whether life insurance is taxable covers that rule and its exceptions for individuals. Section 101(j) is the exception aimed at businesses. It applies to an "employer-owned life insurance contract", which the statute defines as a contract owned by a person engaged in a trade or business, under which that person (or a related person) is directly or indirectly a beneficiary, covering the life of someone who is an employee of that business on the date the contract is issued. For this purpose the statute says an employee includes an officer, a director, and a highly compensated employee.

For such a contract, the general rule in section 101(j)(1) is blunt: the amount excluded from the business's gross income "shall not exceed an amount equal to the sum of the premiums and other amounts paid by the policyholder for the contract." Everything above premiums paid becomes taxable income, unless an exception applies. And the exceptions only apply if the notice and consent requirements were met before the contract was issued.

Worked example, labelled hypothetical. A company owns a $1,000,000 policy on its operations director and has paid $40,000 of premiums when the director dies. If notice and consent were completed properly before issue and an exception applies, the full $1,000,000 can be excluded under the general rule. If they were not, the exclusion is capped at the $40,000 of premiums, and $960,000 is potentially taxable income to the company. The policy, the premium and the death are identical; only a few signed pages differ.

The exceptions, read from the statute

With notice and consent in place, section 101(j)(2) restores the exclusion in two families of cases:

  • The insured's status. The insured was an employee at any time during the 12 months before death, or was, when the contract was issued, a director, a highly compensated employee within the meaning of section 414(q), or a highly compensated individual within the meaning of section 105(h)(5), with "35 percent" substituted for "25 percent" in that provision.
  • Payments to the insured's heirs. The amount is paid to a member of the insured's family, to a designated beneficiary other than the business, to a trust for those people, or to the insured's estate, or it "is used to purchase an equity (or capital or profits) interest in the applicable policyholder" from any of those people. That second clause is the one that covers an entity redemption buy-sell: proceeds the company uses to buy the deceased owner's shares from the estate or family fit the exception, provided notice and consent were done first.

Key person policies often outlive the employment they were bought for. That is why the consent must cover coverage continuing after employment ends, and why the status exception matters: for a former employee it reaches only deaths within 12 months of leaving, unless another exception applies, such as the insured having been a director or highly compensated when the contract was issued.

Notice and consent checklist

The checklist below combines the three statutory requirements in section 101(j)(4) with the additional points in the Form 8925 instructions (Rev. September 2017, checked October 30, 2026). Tick every line before the policy is issued, not after.

#RequirementSourceDone?
1Written notice to the employee that the business intends to insure the employee's lifeSection 101(j)(4)(A)☐
2The notice states the maximum face amount for which the employee could be insured when the contract was issued, in dollars or as a multiple of salary, reflecting what the business reasonably expects to buy during the employee's tenureSection 101(j)(4)(A); Form 8925 instructions☐
3Written notice that the business will be a beneficiary of any proceeds payable on the employee's deathSection 101(j)(4)(C)☐
4Written consent from the employee to being insured, and to coverage continuing after employment endsSection 101(j)(4)(B)☐
5The contract is issued within one year after consent was signed, or before the employee leaves, whichever is earlier; otherwise the consent is not validForm 8925 instructions, line 4a☐
6The "issue date" for this test is the latest of the application date, the coverage effective date, and formal issuanceForm 8925 instructions, issue date of contract☐
7If total coverage on the employee later rises above the amount in the notice, a new notice and consent are obtainedForm 8925 instructions, citing Notice 2009-48☐
8Form 8925 attached to the business's income tax return for every year the contract is in force, reporting covered employees, total coverage in force, and whether a valid consent exists for eachForm 8925 instructions, who must file and when to file☐
9Records kept to support what Form 8925 reportsForm 8925 instructions, recordkeeping☐

Two timing details matter for older policies. The rules apply to contracts issued after August 17, 2006, the enactment date of the Pension Protection Act provision; the effective-date note to section 101 adds that a contract received after that date in a section 1035 exchange for an older contract is not treated as new, but any material increase in the death benefit or other material change makes it a new contract. A business that raises the face amount on an old key person policy may therefore bring it inside the rules without noticing.

Premiums: why none of these are deductible

Section 264(a)(1) says no deduction is allowed for "premiums on any life insurance policy, or endowment or annuity contract, if the taxpayer is directly or indirectly a beneficiary under the policy or contract." A business that owns and benefits from a key person or redemption policy is the beneficiary, so the premium is not deductible. In a cross-purchase, each owner pays for a policy of which that owner is the beneficiary, which lands on the same side of the rule. The usual trade is the one the code sets up: premiums paid with after-tax dollars, death benefits generally excluded from income, as long as section 101(j) and the transfer-for-value rule discussed below do not take the exclusion away. Arrangements where a business pays premiums on a policy owned by or payable to an employee's family are a different category, with their own income tax treatment for the employee, and belong in a conversation with a CPA. The guide to when a life insurance premium is tax deductible works both sides of that arrangement on invented figures.

What Connelly v. United States changed for redemption agreements

On June 6, 2024, the Supreme Court decided Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. 257 (checked October 30, 2026) unanimously. The question was narrow. Everyone agreed that the value of a deceased owner's shares in a closely held corporation follows the corporation's fair market value, and that life insurance proceeds payable to a corporation are an asset that increases that value. The dispute was whether the corporation's contractual obligation to redeem the shares offset the insurance proceeds earmarked to pay for them. The Court said it did not.

The facts and figures, from the opinion

ItemFigure in the opinion
CompanyA small building supply corporation with two shareholders
Ownership385.9 of 500 shares (77.18%) and 114.1 shares (22.82%)
AgreementSurvivor's option to buy; if declined, the corporation must redeem at a price based on an outside appraisal of fair market value
InsuranceThe corporation obtained $3.5 million of life insurance on each owner
Redemption actually paid$3 million, a value agreed between the survivor and the decedent's son rather than set by the appraisal the agreement contemplated
Estate's positionCompany worth $3.86 million excluding the $3 million of proceeds; shares worth about $3 million ($3.86 million × 0.7718)
IRS position, upheldCompany worth $6.86 million ($3.86 million + $3 million); shares worth $5.3 million ($6.86 million × 0.7718)
Additional estate tax assessed$889,914

The Court's reasoning rests on a simple example it gives itself: a corporation holding $10 million in cash, with two shareholders owning 80 and 20 shares. Each share is worth $100,000. Redeeming the 20 shares at fair market value costs $2 million, after which the remaining holder owns 80 shares of an $8 million company, still $100,000 a share. A redemption at fair market value leaves every shareholder's economic position unchanged, so a willing buyer would not treat the obligation to redeem as something that makes the shares worth less. Valuation for the estate tax happens at the moment of death, "before" the company spends the proceeds on the redemption.

The arithmetic, reworked from the opinion's numbers

On the opinion's own figures, the value of the decedent's shares rose from about $2.98 million ($3.86 million × 0.7718) to about $5.29 million ($6.86 million × 0.7718), a difference of roughly $2.3 million in estate value. Meanwhile the estate actually received $3 million for those shares. The estate was valued on more than it was paid, which is the uncomfortable result redemption agreements now have to plan around.

The opinion also concedes a funding problem the petitioner raised: if earmarked proceeds count as a company asset, "Crown would have needed an insurance policy worth far more than $3 million" to redeem at fair market value. The Court answered "True enough." The size of "far more" can be worked out. If the company is worth V before insurance, the departing owner holds a fraction s, and the company receives insurance of I that must equal the shares' fair market value, then I = s × (V + I), which rearranges to I = s × V ÷ (1 − s). With the opinion's figures, $3.86 million × 0.7718 ÷ 0.2282 comes to about $13.05 million of coverage, against the $3.5 million the company actually held. This is our arithmetic on the opinion's model, not a figure in the opinion, and it assumes every dollar of proceeds counts as a company asset at death and the price must equal fair market value.

The formula shows why ownership share matters so much. The table uses a hypothetical company worth $2,000,000 before any insurance.

Departing owner's share (s)Share value ignoring insurance (s × V)Insurance a redemption would need so that I = s × (V + I)Needed coverage as a multiple of s × V
20%$400,000$500,0001.25×
50%$1,000,000$2,000,0002×
60%$1,200,000$3,000,0002.5×
77.18% (the Connelly share)$1,543,600$6,764,242about 4.4×
90%$1,800,000$18,000,00010×

Percentages in the first column are each owner's share of all outstanding shares. The multiple is 1 ÷ (1 − s), so it is modest for minority owners and runs away for a dominant owner. For a business whose majority owner is the person most likely to need buying out, an insurance-funded redemption at true fair market value may be impractical, and a cross-purchase sidesteps the loop because the proceeds never enter the company.

Limits of the holding

The facts also carry a drafting lesson. The Connelly agreement called for an outside appraisal, and the parties agreed a price instead. The opinion notes that a price set in an agreement is ordinarily not decisive for estate tax value under section 2703. A formula or appraisal schedule that is updated and actually used is part of making a plan hold up.

The Court was careful about what it did not decide. In its footnote 2 it said it did not hold "that a redemption obligation can never decrease a corporation's value", giving the example of an obligation that forces a company to sell operating assets and reduces its future earning power. And whether any estate tax is due still depends on the whole estate against the exclusion. The opinion noted the threshold at the time as about $13.6 million; the IRS What's New, Estate and Gift Tax page, checked October 30, 2026, gives a basic exclusion amount of $15,000,000 for deaths in 2026. Many small business estates sit below that, but an owner whose share is valued with insurance proceeds included can be pushed toward it, and some states levy their own estate taxes at lower thresholds. How life insurance enters a gross estate more generally is covered in our guide to life insurance and the estate tax.

Cross-purchase: the policy count and the premium mismatch

The Court itself pointed to the cross-purchase alternative: the owners agree to buy each other's shares at death and each buys a policy on the others, so the proceeds go to the surviving owner, not the company. It also named the drawbacks in the same passage. Each owner must pay premiums on the other, creating a risk that one cannot keep paying, and the structure "would have had its own tax consequences." Two practical problems follow from the arithmetic.

Owners (N)Policies, entity redemption (N)Policies, pure cross-purchase (N × (N − 1))
222
336
4412
5520
6630

First, the count grows fast. With two owners the structures need the same number of policies; with five, a pure cross-purchase needs 20 policies, each with its own owner, beneficiary, premium notice and lapse risk. Some agreements instead use a trustee or escrow agent to hold one policy per owner on behalf of the others, which reduces the paperwork but needs careful drafting so that the arrangement and any later transfers fit the tax rules.

Second, premiums fall unevenly. In a cross-purchase each owner insures the others' stakes. The owner with the smaller stake buys coverage on the owner with the larger stake, so the minority owner pays for the bigger policy, and if the majority owner is also older, the premium per $1,000 is typically higher too. On the Connelly ownership split, the 22.82% owner would be buying coverage sized to a 77.18% stake. Agreements sometimes address this with compensation adjustments, but those carry their own income tax effects. Health matters as well: if one owner is rated or declined, the plan has to work around that owner, and nothing on this site predicts how any applicant would be classed; our guide to health classes explains what underwriters weigh.

Restructuring an existing plan: the transfer-for-value trap

After Connelly, many businesses with redemption agreements considered moving existing company-owned policies to the owners to convert to a cross-purchase. A transfer of a policy for value can cost the death benefit its tax-free status. Section 101(a)(2) says that when a life insurance contract or an interest in it is transferred "for a valuable consideration, by assignment or otherwise," the exclusion is capped at the consideration paid plus premiums and other amounts the transferee pays afterward.

The statute lists the transfers that escape the cap: a transfer where the transferee's basis is figured by reference to the transferor's basis, or a transfer "to the insured, to a partner of the insured, to a partnership in which the insured is a partner, or to a corporation in which the insured is a shareholder or officer." Read that list against a typical corporate restructuring. A corporation selling a policy on one shareholder to a fellow shareholder is not on the list: a co-shareholder is not "a partner of the insured" merely by owning stock in the same corporation. Owners of a business taxed as a partnership have more room, because transfers to partners and partnerships are excepted. Section 101(a)(3) adds a separate set of rules for commercial sales to unrelated buyers, called reportable policy sales.

Moving a policy is also a change of owner and often of beneficiary, with the insurer's own forms and a review of what is lost or kept. Our guides to changing a beneficiary and replacing a policy cover those mechanics. None of the tax analysis here substitutes for a CPA reviewing the specific transfer before it happens; the cost of getting it wrong arrives only at death, when it can no longer be fixed.

Buyouts and owners the standard structures do not cover

The structure table assumes two or more owners, a death, and a plan that owns the right policies. Four common situations fall outside it.

  • A single-owner business. There is no co-owner to buy the shares, so a buy-sell agreement needs a named outside buyer, often a key employee. If the buyer is an employee, who owns the policy decides whether section 101(j) applies.
  • Disability, retirement and departure. Most buy-sell agreements also trigger on disability, retirement, divorce or an owner simply leaving. Life insurance funds only the death trigger. A plan that funds death and leaves disability to a promissory note should say so openly.
  • LLCs and continuity. The Small Business Administration's business structure guide, checked October 30, 2026, notes that when a member joins or leaves an LLC, some states may require the LLC to be dissolved and re-formed with new membership, unless there is already an agreement in place for buying, selling and transferring ownership. A funded buy-sell can be part of that continuity plan.
  • Group coverage confusion. A business owner covered under the company's group life plan has personal coverage tied to employment, not a buyout plan. How group coverage ends at a job change is explained in employer group life gaps.

Seven failure points, sorted by the adviser who catches them

Funded plans rarely fail on the big structural choice. They fail on a date, a form or a figure that nobody rechecked. Each failure point below is paired with the adviser best placed to catch it and the question that surfaces it.

For the CPA

  1. Consent signed after the policy was issued. The statute requires notice and consent before issuance, and a form signed later does not cure it. Ask: does every employer-owned contract have documented notice and consent dated before issue?
  2. A missing Form 8925. It is due with the return for every year an employer-owned contract issued after August 17, 2006 is in force. Ask: are we filing it, and does each year's count match the policies the business owns?
  3. A redemption funded at yesterday's value. After Connelly, a redemption plan sized to the company's value without insurance may fall well short of fair market value with insurance included, especially for a majority owner. Ask: on our numbers, what is the estimated estate tax value of each owner's share with insurance proceeds counted?
  4. A policy transfer made to fix the structure without tax review. The transfer-for-value cap can turn a tax-free benefit into taxable income. Ask: would any proposed transfer fall outside the section 101(a)(2) exceptions?

For the business attorney

  1. An agreement nobody has updated. Ownership percentages, company value and the owners' ages all change, and a buy-sell written for a two-owner startup rarely fits the same business ten years later. Ask: does the agreement make the company, the owners, or both responsible for buying? How is the price set, and when was the formula last updated? Which events trigger a buyout, and how is each funded? If we restructure after Connelly, what does an amendment require?

For a licensed agent in your state

  1. Coverage raised without a new notice. Coverage above the maximum face amount in the notice needs a fresh notice and consent, and a material increase can make an old contract new. Ask: for each insured, what is the face amount, term and premium on the quote we hold, and is it within the amount in the signed notice?
  2. A cross-purchase policy left to lapse. When each owner pays a premium on the other, a missed payment can leave the buyout unfunded without the other owner knowing, which is why agreements commonly require proof of payment each year. Ask: do the policy owner and beneficiary match the agreement, and can lapse notices go to both owners? If owners differ in age or health, how do premiums split under each structure?

Put the quotes you receive into the quote worksheet to compare total paid and cost per $1,000 of coverage side by side; it computes only what you enter, and stores and sends nothing.

This page is education only. TrueLifeCost does not sell insurance or provide quotes, and nothing here is legal or tax advice for a specific business. The statute, the regulations, the opinion and your agreement control over any summary on this page. More on how ownership, beneficiaries and estates interact is collected on the tax, estate and benefits hub.

The fastest audit an owner can run alone takes one sheet of paper. List every policy that funds the agreement, with its owner and its beneficiary in two columns, and hold that list against the structure table at the top of this page. A company-owned policy on an employee or owner sends you to the federal income tax rules for death benefits, because the section 101(j) cap separates a tax-free benefit from a taxable one.

Sources

Business life insurance questions, answered briefly

Is key person life insurance tax deductible?

No. Section 264(a)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code disallows a deduction for premiums on a life insurance policy when the taxpayer is directly or indirectly a beneficiary, and a business that owns and receives the benefit of a key person policy is the beneficiary. The usual trade is after-tax premiums in exchange for a death benefit that is generally excluded from income, provided the section 101(j) notice and consent rules were met before the policy was issued.

Is the death benefit from a key person policy taxable to the business?

It can be. For an employer-owned contract, section 101(j) caps the tax-free amount at the premiums the business paid unless written notice and consent were completed before issue and an exception applies, such as the insured having been an employee within 12 months of death or a director or highly compensated employee when the contract was issued. Without that paperwork, the amount above premiums paid is potentially taxable income.

What did Connelly v. United States decide?

On June 6, 2024, the Supreme Court held unanimously that a corporation's contractual obligation to redeem a deceased shareholder's shares at fair market value did not offset the life insurance proceeds the corporation received to fund that redemption. On the opinion's figures, the company's value rose from $3.86 million to $6.86 million with the $3 million of proceeds counted, the 77.18% stake was valued at $5.3 million rather than about $3 million, and the estate owed an additional $889,914.

Does Connelly affect cross-purchase buy-sell agreements?

The case concerned a redemption obligation, and the Court itself described a cross-purchase as an option the owners could have used: the proceeds would have gone directly to the surviving owner rather than to the company, so they would not have raised the company's value. The Court also noted the cross-purchase drawbacks, including the risk that an owner cannot keep paying premiums on the other, and that it carries its own tax consequences.

How many policies does a cross-purchase agreement need?

In a pure cross-purchase each owner holds a policy on every other owner, so N owners need N × (N − 1) policies: 2 for two owners, 6 for three, 12 for four and 20 for five. An entity redemption needs one policy per owner. Some agreements use a trustee or escrow arrangement to hold one policy per owner for the others, which needs careful drafting.

Can we just transfer our company-owned policies to the owners after Connelly?

Not without tax review. Section 101(a)(2) caps the tax-free death benefit when a policy is transferred for value, and its exceptions cover transfers to the insured, a partner of the insured, a partnership in which the insured is a partner, or a corporation in which the insured is a shareholder or officer. A sale from a corporation to a fellow shareholder is not on that list, so a CPA should review any transfer before it is made.